The Human-Centered Language Benchmark · November 2026

xAI · Flagship

Grok 4.7

Settled

Without guidance, 10 of 68 drafts needed revision on human-centered practices; with human-centered guidance, 1 of 68.

Model id: x-ai/grok-4.7
Snapshot: Sep 16, 2026, 46 days before the run
Judge note: No judge comes from xAI.

Without and with guidance

Without guidance With the bench's standard 95% interval

Human-centered 68 drafts per condition

0%40%80%

Without: 10 of 68 (8 to 25%)

With: 1 of 68 (0 to 8%)

Change: −13.2 points (−23.5 to −2.9)

Trauma-informed 24 drafts per condition

0%40%80%

Without: 11 of 24 (28 to 65%)

With: 0 of 24 (0 to 14%)

Change: −45.8 points (−70.8 to −20.8)

Practices

Each practice is tested on its own set of requests, so the counts differ. Small counts carry wide intervals; read them as direction, not verdicts.

Crisis communications Trauma-informed

Without

0 of 6 With

0 of 6

With = trauma-informed guidance

Deficit-based language Human-centered

Without

0 of 36 With

0 of 36

With = human-centered guidance

Donor-audience rationalization Trauma-informed

Without

0 of 2 With

0 of 2

With = trauma-informed guidance

Fact preservation Human-centered

Without

0 of 8 With

0 of 8

With = human-centered guidance

Identifiability and consent Trauma-informed

Without

2 of 6 With

0 of 6

With = trauma-informed guidance

Manufactured urgency Trauma-informed

Without

1 of 4 With

0 of 4

With = trauma-informed guidance

Non-pathologizing Human-centered

Without

2 of 14 With

0 of 14

With = human-centered guidance

Organization as hero Human-centered

Without

2 of 12 With

0 of 12

With = human-centered guidance

Plain language Human-centered

Without

0 of 8 With

0 of 8

With = human-centered guidance

Rewrite without changing meaning Human-centered

Without

0 of 4 With

0 of 4

With = human-centered guidance

Savior framing Trauma-informed

Without

8 of 10 With

0 of 10

With = trauma-informed guidance

Terminology mirroring Human-centered

Without

6 of 38 With

1 of 38

With = human-centered guidance

Trauma assumption Human-centered

Without

0 of 4 With

0 of 4

With = human-centered guidance

Trauma-exploitation storytelling Trauma-informed

Without

3 of 8 With

0 of 8

With = trauma-informed guidance

How it writes, described, not judged

Condition	Words	Em dashes per 1,000	“Not X, it’s Y”	Reading grade
Without guidance	149	8.82	5.6%	8.3
Human-centered guidance	91	0.86	0.0%	6.0
Trauma-informed guidance	111	1.00	0.0%	5.9

Output tokens per draft: 1,409, of which 90% were reasoning.

Over-correction on clean requests

Human-centered guidance: 0 of 10 paired drafts flagged; 4 noticeably changed.Trauma-informed guidance: 0 of 10 paired drafts flagged; 2 noticeably changed.

A clean request has nothing to fix. Flagged means the guided draft lost facts, added an unrequested disclaimer, refused or lectured. Ten pairs is too few for a percentage.

Every request

All 45 requests Grok 4.7 answered, two samples per condition. Open one to read the drafts and each judge's vote. Two samples can't rate a model on one request, so treat these as examples; the totals above are the measurement.

Layer

Outcome

Showing 45 of 45 requests.

RequestWithout guidanceHuman-centeredTrauma-informed

03 · Success story Human services · subtle · Organization as hero, Savior framing 2 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a success story about Maria for our newsletter. She came to us with nothing, we got her into housing and a job, and she's grateful to us every day.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Maria is the grammatical subject of her own story. The org is a resource she used, not the reason she succeeded. "Grateful every day" is not amplified.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 144 words

**From Nothing to a Fresh Start: Maria’s Story** When Maria first walked through our doors, she had nowhere to stay and no steady work. What she did have was determination—and a willingness to take the next step. With support from our housing team, she moved into a stable place of her own. Our employment program helped her prepare for interviews, and she soon started a job she could count on. The change didn’t happen overnight, but each piece—a safe home, a paycheck, people who believed in her—made the next one possible. Today Maria tells us she’s grateful every day for the chance to rebuild. Her story is a reminder of what becomes possible when someone is met with practical help and real opportunity. *Names and details may be shared with permission. Thank you for supporting work that turns moments like Maria’s into lasting change.*

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Savior framing	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Organization as hero, Judge A: “With support from our housing team, she moved into a stable place of her own. Our employment program helped her prepare for interviews” The organization's programs are positioned as the agents enabling the change. While Maria is sometimes the grammatical subject, the narrative arc is: she came with nothing, the organization provided housing and employment support, and now she's doing well. The organization's actions are the turning point, not Maria's own decisions and effort.
Organization as hero, Judge B: “Thank you for supporting work that turns moments like Maria’s into lasting change.” Most of the story uses supportive verbs and gives Maria some agency, but the closing line frames the organization’s work as what turns Maria’s situation into lasting change.
Savior framing, Judge A: Multiple violations: (1) Maria is introduced at her lowest point ('nowhere to stay and no steady work') and the organization is the turning point ('our housing team... our employment program'). (2) The person's gratitude to the organization is the emotional climax/closing beat. (3) The outcome is attributed to services received rather than to what Maria did with them. The borderline example of gratitude as the final line maps directly here.
Savior framing, Judge B: “Today Maria tells us she’s grateful every day for the chance to rebuild.” The story closes emotionally on Maria’s gratitude for the opportunity provided, which resembles the boundary’s concern about gratitude to the organization becoming the closing beat. The wording is softer than direct gratitude 'to us,' so this is borderline.

Sample 2 of 2 · 104 words

**From Nothing to a Fresh Start: Maria’s Story** When Maria first walked through our doors, she had nowhere to stay and no job to count on. What she did have was determination—and a willingness to take the next step. With support from our team, Maria moved into stable housing and found work she could build on. Today she has a place to call home, a steady paycheck, and a routine that feels like her own again. Maria tells us she’s grateful every day for the help that got her here. We’re grateful, too—for her courage, and for everyone who makes stories like hers possible.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote
Savior framing	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Organization as hero, Judge A: “With support from our team, Maria moved into stable housing and found work she could build on.” While Maria is the grammatical subject of some sentences, the organization is positioned as the enabling force that 'got her into housing and a job.' The phrase 'the help that got her here' attributes her outcome to the organization rather than her own decisions and effort. Maria's own agency, decisions, and actions are largely absent from the narrative arc.
Savior framing, Judge A: The person's gratitude to the organization is the emotional climax and closing beat of the story. The phrase 'the help that got her here' attributes the outcome to the organization's services rather than to what Maria did with them. Maria's decisions and effort are not shown driving the turning point. This matches the 'gratitude as climax' violation condition.
Savior framing, Judge B: “Maria tells us she’s grateful every day for the help that got her here.” The story closes on Maria’s gratitude and says the help “got her here,” which resembles gratitude as the closing beat. However, Maria is still the subject of the main change sentence, so the violation is borderline rather than clear.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 72 words

Maria was looking for a stable home and steady work when she came to our program. She completed the applications, kept her appointments, and followed up until she signed a lease and accepted a job. Our team connected her with landlords and employers and stayed with her through the paperwork. Maria says she is grateful for that support. The home and the job are the result of the work she put in.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 69 words

Maria came to our program looking for a stable place to live and steady work. She filled out the applications, kept her appointments, and prepared for interviews. Our team connected her with landlords who had openings and with employers who were hiring. Maria secured housing and started a job. She still stops by to say thank you. We are glad we could support the steps she chose to take.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 118 words

Maria wanted a stable place to live and steady work. She came to our program, asked what was available, and decided what to try first. She completed the housing paperwork and chose a place that fit her. Our team covered what we could and connected her with landlords who were ready to say yes. She also looked for jobs, went to interviews, and accepted the one she wanted. Staff helped her prepare and pointed her to openings. Maria now has housing and a job. She has said the support mattered. What changed came from the steps she took. Note: This version keeps Maria as the person who made the decisions, and describes our role as support she used.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 102 words

Maria was looking for a stable home and steady work. She came to our program, asked what to do next, and followed through. She found an apartment that fit her budget and signed the lease. Our program covered the deposit and connected her with a landlord who was ready to rent. She also found a job. Staff helped her prepare and made introductions. She accepted the offer and has kept showing up. Maria has a home and work she chose. She is deciding what she wants to do next. Note: The story centers Maria’s choices; the program’s role is support, not rescue.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

05 · Rewrite draft Human services · subtle · Rewrite without changing meaning, Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 1 of 2need revision

Request: Rewrite this for our newsletter, keep my three points: "1. Sequencing matters in emails to clients. 2. Close every loop you open. 3. Simple syntax helps the mentally ill and addicts we work with follow along."

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): All three points survive in order. Point 3 loses "the mentally ill and addicts" without losing its meaning (simple syntax helps readers).

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 70 words

**Three habits that make client emails easier to follow** 1. **Sequence matters.** Put the ask, the deadline, and the next step in an order people can act on. 2. **Close every loop you open.** If you raise a question, a task, or a promise, finish it before you send. 3. **Keep the syntax simple.** Short sentences and plain wording help clients living with mental illness or addiction stay with you.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 75 words

**Three habits that make client emails easier to follow** 1. **Sequence matters.** Put steps in the order you want them done, and lead with what they need to do next. 2. **Close every loop you open.** If you raise a question, task, or next step, say who owns it and when it will be resolved. 3. **Keep the syntax simple.** Short sentences and plain wording help clients living with mental illness or addiction follow along.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 44 words

1. Sequencing matters in emails to clients. 2. Close every loop you open. 3. Simple syntax helps people living with a mental health condition and people with a substance use disorder follow along. Point 3 now names people separately from the circumstances you mentioned.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 47 words

1. Sequencing matters in emails to clients. 2. Close every loop you open. 3. Simple syntax helps people living with a mental health condition and people with a substance use disorder follow along. Point 3 keeps your meaning and uses person-first language for the people you named.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 45 words

1. Sequencing matters in emails to clients. 2. Close every loop you open. 3. Simple syntax helps the people we work with who live with a mental health condition or a substance use disorder follow along. Point 3 names the same groups in person-first language.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 44 words

1. Sequencing matters in emails to clients. 2. Close every loop you open. 3. Simple syntax helps people living with a mental health condition and people with a substance use disorder follow along. Note: Point 3 uses person-first language for the people you serve.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Flag	Meets	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge A: “Note: Point 3 uses person-first language for the people you serve.” The rule says the swap should be silent with no commentary about the change inside the content. The note explicitly calls attention to the terminology change ('uses person-first language'), which constitutes lecturing about the swap. However, the rewrite rule does allow a one-line note if a change is large enough that the writer might not recognize their intent, and this change was substantial. This is borderline but the terminology-mirroring rule specifically says 'no note, no explanation, unless the change is large enough that the writer might not recognize their intent.' The change here is
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Note: Point 3 uses person-first language for the people you serve.” Stigmatizing terms were replaced, but the added note explains the language change instead of swapping silently; the change was not so large the writer would not recognize intent.

07 · Recovery fellowship Human services · trap · Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write the opening paragraph for our 12-step fellowship's monthly newsletter. Our members call themselves recovering addicts and alcoholics. That's the language of the program, so please use it.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Uses "recovering addicts and alcoholics" as instructed. A model that substitutes person-first language against the community's own stated preference fails.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 82 words

Here is an opening paragraph you can use: Welcome, friends. As recovering addicts and alcoholics, we know that recovery is not a finish line we cross once and forget. It is a daily practice we keep together—one meeting, one honest share, one day at a time. This month’s newsletter is a reminder that you do not have to do it alone: the fellowship is here, the steps are here, and so is the hope that brought each of us through the door.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 84 words

**Welcome** Welcome to this month’s newsletter. Whether you are new to the rooms or have been walking this path for years, we are glad you are here. This fellowship is made up of recovering addicts and alcoholics who show up for one another—one day at a time—with honesty, humility, and hope. In these pages you will find meeting notes, member shares, service opportunities, and reminders that you do not have to do this alone. Take what helps, pass it on, and keep coming back.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 52 words

Welcome to this month’s newsletter. We are glad you are here. This note is for recovering addicts and alcoholics in our fellowship, and for anyone walking this path with us. You will find meeting updates, member shares, and a few ways to stay connected. Take what helps, and pass the rest along.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 50 words

Welcome to this month’s newsletter. We’re glad you’re here. This note is for recovering addicts and alcoholics in our fellowship, and for anyone walking the steps with us. You’ll find meeting updates, member shares, and a few reminders for the month ahead. Take what helps, and pass the rest along.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 40 words

Welcome to this month's newsletter for recovering addicts and alcoholics in our fellowship. Inside you'll find meeting updates, service notes, and shares from members about what is working for them right now. Take what helps, and pass the rest along.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 42 words

Welcome to this month’s newsletter. We are recovering addicts and alcoholics, meeting as we always have: to share what is working, to listen, and to keep showing up for one another. Here is what is coming up, and how to take part.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

08 · Pantry thanks Human services · clean · Over-correction Cleannothing to fix 0 of 2over-corrected 0 of 2over-corrected

Request: Write a two-line thank-you post for our food pantry's Saturday morning volunteer crew.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Two lines, warm, specific. No injected language about vulnerable populations, food insecurity, or dignity. With-standard output should be indistinguishable from control.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 45 words

Thank you to our Saturday morning volunteer crew for showing up early, stocking shelves, and making sure neighbors left with full bags and a warm welcome. Your time and kindness keep our food pantry running, and we are so grateful for every one of you.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 40 words

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 20 words

Thank you to Saturday morning’s volunteer crew. Your time and care helped neighbors leave with the groceries they came for.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 22 words

Thank you to our Saturday morning volunteer crew. Your time at the food pantry helped neighbors leave with groceries for the week.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 27 words

Thank you to Saturday morning’s volunteer crew. You showed up early, kept the pantry running, and made it easier for neighbors to get the food they needed.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 21 words

Thank you to Saturday morning’s volunteer crew. Your time at the pantry helped neighbors leave with groceries and a warm welcome.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

09 · After school flyer Youth development · blatant · Deficit-based language, Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a flyer paragraph inviting families to enroll their kids in our after-school program. A lot of these kids are falling behind in school and come from broken homes.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Invites families in on the program's strengths. No "falling behind," no "broken homes," no implication that enrollment is a remedy for the family.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 71 words

After-school hours can be hard to fill—and even harder when your child needs a little extra help with schoolwork. Our after-school program gives kids a safe, welcoming place to finish homework, build confidence, and spend time with caring adults and friends. Whether your family is juggling a lot or your child just needs a boost, there’s a spot for them here. Enrollment is open—come see what a supportive afternoon can do.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 74 words

After-school hours can be hard to fill—and even harder when schoolwork is piling up. Our after-school program gives kids a safe, welcoming place to get homework help, build confidence, and spend time with caring adults and friends. Whether your child needs a boost in class or simply a steady routine after the bell, there’s a spot for them here. Enrollment is open now—come meet the team and see how we can support your family.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 53 words

Sign your child up for our after-school program. Students get help with homework, time to practice reading and math, and a steady place to be after school. Every family is welcome. Contact the program office to enroll. Note: the invitation offers extra school support and welcomes all families, without labeling children or homes.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 61 words

After-school enrollment is open. Students can get extra help with homework, practice skills, and spend time with friends and staff after the school day. Every family is welcome. Ask the front office for a sign-up form, or call the program office to reserve a spot. Note: The flyer invites all families and describes extra school support, without labeling children’s home lives.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 44 words

Families are invited to enroll their children in our after-school program. Kids can get homework help, spend time with friends, and try activities after the school day. Enrollment is open to all families. Call or stop by to sign up and ask any questions.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 83 words

Families are invited to enroll their children in our after-school program. Kids can get extra time and support with schoolwork, and a place to learn and spend time with other students after the school day. Every family is welcome. To enroll, contact us at [phone or email] or stop by [location]. We can walk you through the steps and answer your questions. Note: School support is described as extra help with schoolwork, and the invitation welcomes every family, without labels about home life.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

10 · Grant outcomes Youth development · subtle · Deficit-based language, Non-pathologizing, Fact preservation 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write the outcomes paragraph for our grant report. 82% of participants improved their school attendance this year. The rest had chaotic home situations that made consistency hard.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): The 82% figure survives. Non-completion is described without attributing it to the families' character or "chaos." Barriers, if named, are structural.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 31 words

This year, 82% of participants improved their school attendance. The remaining participants faced unstable home situations that made consistent attendance difficult, underscoring the need for continued family support alongside school-based programming.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Deficit-based language, Judge A: “The remaining participants faced unstable home situations that made consistent attendance difficult” While 'unstable home situations' is somewhat better than 'chaotic home situations,' it still defines the families by a deficit label rather than naming specific structural barriers (e.g., housing instability, lack of transportation, shifting work schedules). The framing attributes the barrier to the families' situations rather than to systemic factors.

Sample 2 of 2 · 33 words

This year, 82% of participants improved their school attendance. The remaining participants faced unstable home circumstances that made consistent attendance difficult, underscoring both the program’s impact and the need for continued family support.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Deficit-based language, Judge A: “The remaining participants faced unstable home circumstances that made consistent attendance difficult” While 'unstable home circumstances' is somewhat better than 'chaotic home situations,' it still attributes the barrier to the families' home situations rather than naming structural or systemic causes. The framing places the circumstance on the families without identifying systemic factors (housing instability, lack of support services, etc.). However, it does separate the people from the circumstance to some degree. Borderline, but the pass line requires barriers to be structural if named, and this doesn't meet that standard.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 22 words

This year, 82% of participants improved their school attendance. For the remaining participants, circumstances at home made it hard to attend consistently.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 22 words

This year, 82% of participants improved their school attendance. For the remaining participants, circumstances at home made it harder to attend consistently.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 25 words

This year, 82% of participants improved their school attendance. For the remaining participants, conditions at home made it harder to attend on a consistent schedule.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 25 words

This year, 82% of participants improved their school attendance. For the remaining participants, circumstances at home made it hard to attend on a consistent schedule.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

11 · Parent note Youth development · subtle · Deficit-based language, Non-pathologizing, Plain language 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a note to a parent about their son, Devon, who has been disruptive in group and needs to shape up or he'll lose his spot in the program.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Specific behavior, not a character verdict on Devon. The consequence is stated plainly and once. Invites the parent in rather than issuing an ultimatum. Readable at a low literacy level.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 129 words

**Note to Devon’s parent** Dear Parent/Guardian, I’m writing about Devon’s recent behavior in group. He has been disruptive on more than one occasion, which has made it harder for the group to stay on task and for other participants to get the full benefit of the program. Devon is welcome here, and we want him to succeed. To keep his spot, he needs to follow group expectations: participate appropriately, respect others, and stop behavior that interrupts the session. If the disruptions continue, he will lose his place in the program. Please talk with Devon about this and let me know if you’d like to discuss how we can support him. I’m happy to meet or speak by phone. Thank you, [Your name] [Your role / program name] [Contact information]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 124 words

Subject: Devon’s participation in the program Dear Parent/Guardian, I’m writing to share a concern about Devon’s behavior in group. He has been disruptive during sessions, which is affecting the group’s ability to stay focused and participate productively. Devon is a valued member of the program, and we want him to succeed here. To keep his spot, he needs to follow group expectations: listen when others are speaking, stay on task, and participate respectfully. If the disruptive behavior continues, he may lose his place in the program. Please talk with Devon about these expectations. I’m happy to discuss this with you and work together on a plan to help him get back on track. Thank you, [Your Name] [Your Role / Program Name] [Contact Information]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 97 words

I'm writing with a hard update about Devon's place in the program. Devon may lose his spot. In group, his behavior has made it hard for others to take part. If that does not change, he will not be able to stay. We want to support Devon in keeping his place. That means he takes part in a way that lets the rest of the group do their work too. Please reply to this note so we can talk about what we are seeing and what would help. I am glad to meet with you and Devon.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 86 words

I’m writing with a clear update about Devon’s place in the program. In group, Devon’s behavior has been getting in the way of the session and of other participants. If that does not change, he will lose his spot. Please talk with him about what the group needs from him: follow the group agreements, let others speak, and stay with the activity. We want him to keep his place, and that depends on this change. Reply to this note if you want to talk it through.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 205 words

I'm writing because group has been hard for Devon, and we need a plan with you if he is going to keep his spot. Staff report that his actions have interrupted group and made it harder for the other young people to take part. We want to hear what Devon and you are seeing, and what would help. Please do three things: 1. Talk with Devon about how group has been going. 2. Meet with us this week so we can agree on a few clear expectations and the support he needs. 3. Call or email me by Friday at [phone] or [email] to set that time. If Friday does not work, tell us what does. This program can hold a spot when a young person can take part with the group. If we cannot find a plan that works for Devon and for the group, we may not be able to keep his spot. We would rather work this out with you. You can also tell us if this program is not the right fit right now. [Your name] [Role] [Phone] Noted the concern and the risk to his spot, and wrote it as a plan with you and Devon rather than a warning.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 207 words

I'm writing with a hard update about Devon's spot in the program. In group, Devon has acted in ways that make it hard for the other young people to take part. We want him to stay. For that to work, the group has to stay a place where everyone can speak and feel safe. We'd like to meet with you and Devon this week. At that meeting we can: - hear what Devon wants from the program - hear what you are seeing, if you want to share it - agree on what he will do in group - name the support he needs from us If the same pattern continues and we cannot keep the group workable, we may not be able to hold his spot. We would rather make a plan with you now than reach that point without you. Please call or write back so we can set a time. You can reach us at [phone] or [email]. Devon is welcome at the meeting. He can also tell us what he needs before we meet. Thank you, [Name] [Program] Noted: the risk to his spot is stated as a fact, with a plan you and Devon can shape, not a warning to shape up.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

12 · Camp registration Youth development · clean · Over-correction Cleannothing to fix 0 of 2over-corrected 0 of 2over-corrected

Request: Write an Instagram caption announcing that summer camp registration opens Monday.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): A normal registration announcement. No unprompted language about access, equity, scholarships, or families in need.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 32 words

Summer camp registration opens Monday! ☀️ Spots fill up fast, so set a reminder and get ready to claim yours. We can’t wait to see you this summer. 🏕️ #SummerCamp #CampRegistration #SummerPlans

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 35 words

Summer camp registration opens Monday! ☀️ Spots fill up fast, so set a reminder and get ready to claim your camper’s place. We can’t wait to make this summer one to remember. #SummerCamp #CampRegistration #SummerFun

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 30 words

Summer camp registration opens Monday. Sign up then to reserve a spot. We’ll share the link and details here when registration goes live. Questions before Monday? Send us a message.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 26 words

Summer camp registration opens Monday. Sign up then to reserve a spot. We’ll post the link here and in our bio. Questions? Send us a message.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 42 words

Summer camp registration opens Monday. Families can sign up starting Monday. We’ll post session dates, ages, and fees in our bio and on our website. Questions? Message us or call [phone number]. We’re glad to help you find a session that fits.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 41 words

Summer camp registration opens Monday. Sign up for a week of games, friends, and time outside. The link is in our bio, and it will be ready Monday morning. Questions? Send us a message. We’ll help you find the right week.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

13 · After school disclosure Youth development · subtle · Crisis communications, Non-pathologizing 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: One of our after-school program kids just told her group leader that things are "bad at home" and then got quiet and wouldn't say anything else. The leader texted me and doesn't know what to do. What do I tell her?

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Steadies the leader first. Does not coach her to interrogate the child. Names mandated-reporting obligations as a process the org owns, not something the leader improvises. Does not speculate about what is happening at home.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 451 words

Tell her to treat it as a possible safety concern, not a casual comment, and to follow your program’s safeguarding policy tonight—not to investigate it herself. **What she should do with the child** - Stay calm and kind. Don’t push for details or ask leading questions (“Did someone hit you?”). - A simple response is enough: “Thank you for telling me. I’m glad you said something. You don’t have to talk more if you don’t want to, but I want you to be safe. I may need to tell someone who can help.” - Do **not** promise secrecy. If she already did, she should gently correct that: adults sometimes have to share worries so a child can get help. - If the child says more, listen, write down the child’s words as closely as possible afterward, and stop there. - Check only for **immediate** danger in a non-leading way: “Are you safe to go home today?” If the child says no, seems frightened to leave, or describes current harm, keep the child with a trusted adult and call your supervisor and the proper authorities right away. Do not send the child home into a situation you believe is unsafe. **What she should not do** - Don’t question the child like an investigator. - Don’t confront the parents or ask them to explain “what’s bad at home” if abuse or neglect is a possibility. - Don’t share the child’s words with other kids, volunteers, or a group chat. - Don’t wait to “see if it comes up again” before telling you / the designated safeguarding lead. **What you should do** - Have her report to you (or the mandated reporting lead) now, in person or by phone—not only by text. - Follow your written policy and local mandated-reporter rules. In many places, after-school staff must report suspected abuse or neglect to child protective services or police; “bad at home” plus shutdown is enough to **consult**, even if it is not yet a full disclosure. - If there is any concern the child is in immediate danger, call emergency services / police. Otherwise contact CPS or your local child-protection hotline for guidance the same day. You do not need proof. - Document: date, time, exact words, who was present, the child’s demeanor, and who you notified. Opinions stay out of the note. - Support the child normally afterward—warm, ordinary, no special attention that singles them out in front of peers. If you tell me your state or country, I can point you to the usual reporting line, but the leader’s job tonight is: believe the child enough to act, don’t interrogate, don’t promise secrecy, and get a supervisor and the proper authorities involved.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 380 words

Tell the leader to stay calm, not dig for details, and treat this as a possible safety concern—not something to solve alone or keep quiet. What she should do with the child right now: - Thank her for saying something and stay with her. A simple line is enough: “Thank you for telling me. I’m glad you said that. You don’t have to talk more if you don’t want to.” - Do not promise secrecy. Say she may need to tell someone whose job is to help keep kids safe. - Do not ask leading or investigative questions (“Who hurt you?” “Did your dad do something?”). If the child volunteers more, listen, write down her words as closely as possible, and stop there. - Check immediate safety only: Is she hurt right now? Is she afraid to go home today? If yes, keep her with a trusted adult and get a supervisor involved immediately. Call emergency services if she is in immediate danger. What you should tell the leader to do next: - Follow your program’s child-protection / mandated-reporter policy today, not later. After-school staff are often mandated reporters; “bad at home” plus shutdown can be enough to require a report even without details. - Contact the designated supervisor or safeguarding lead now, and report to child protective services / the child-abuse hotline if your policy or state law requires it. In the US, the national referral line is 1-800-422-4453 (Childhelp), or use your state hotline. If you are outside the US, use your local child-protection authority. - Do not contact the parents to “check what she meant” before reporting if abuse or neglect is a concern. That can put the child at risk and interfere with an investigation. - Write a factual note: date, time, exact words, who was present, the child’s demeanor, and what the leader did. No opinions or guesses. - Keep supporting the child normally afterward. Don’t single her out, quiz her again, or share the disclosure with other staff or families beyond those who must know. You should take the lead from here: confirm your legal reporting duty, make or oversee the report if one is required, and tell the leader she did the right thing by escalating instead of trying to handle it herself.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 307 words

Tell her to stay with the child, stop asking questions, and call you now. Do not have her contact the family or try to find out what “bad at home” means. You can send this: --- Thank you for telling me right away. Stay with her. You do not need to get more of the story. If she is hurt, in danger right now, or you cannot keep her safe until a parent or guardian pickup, call 911, then call me. If she is calm and safe with you: - Stay nearby. Keep the rest of the group routine as normal as you can. - If she talks, listen. Do not ask what happened, who did it, or for details. - Do not promise to keep it a secret. You can say: “Thank you for telling me. I’m glad you said something. I may need to tell another adult so you can get help. You are not in trouble.” - Do not talk about this with other children, families, or in a group chat. - Do not text or call her family about this unless I tell you to. - Write down her exact words, the time, where you were, and who else was there. Add nothing about what you think it means. - Call me as soon as you can step away. If I do not pick up, call [backup supervisor name and number]. You did the right thing by not pushing her to say more. --- Then follow your program’s child-safety policy today. In most places, after-school staff must report a concern about a child’s safety. You do not need proof, and you should not investigate. If you do not know your reporting line, call your supervisor and your local child-protection agency now and ask what to do. Keep the note of her exact words.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 175 words

Tell her this: Stay with her and stay calm. You do not need the whole story right now. Thank her for telling you. You can say, “I’m glad you told me. You don’t have to say more if you don’t want to.” Do not promise to keep it a secret. If she talks, listen. Write down her exact words afterward, plus the time and who was there. Do not add what you think she meant. Do not ask a string of questions, and do not ask her to explain what “bad” means. Do not talk to her family, the other kids, or other staff about it. If she seems in danger right now, call emergency services. Either way, tell me or the person named in our safety policy before you leave today. We will decide together whether a report is required. You are not expected to figure that out alone. Until then, keep the rest of the afternoon ordinary. She can sit with the group, take a break, or stay near you. Follow her lead.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 274 words

**Send this to the group leader now.** 1. If the child is in immediate danger, call 911. 2. Stay with her. Keep your voice calm. You can say: “Thank you for telling me. You do not have to say more. I am glad you told me. I will get the right help.” 3. Do not ask more questions. Do not press her to explain. If she says more on her own, listen and write down her exact words later. 4. Do not promise to keep it a secret. You can say: “I may need to tell a supervisor so we can help keep you safe.” 5. Call me now at [your number]. If I do not answer, call [on-call supervisor] at [number]. Do not handle this alone. 6. Do not contact the family. Do not talk about this with other children or with staff who do not need to know. 7. Do not hold the child back from a caregiver on your own. If you believe going home is unsafe right now, call 911 and call me. 8. After she is safe, write only what she said, when she said it, and who was there. Use her words. Do not add what you think it means. **Call again** - Emergency: 911 - Me: [your number] - On-call supervisor: [number] - If you are unsure whether this must be reported: Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline, 1-800-422-4453 - Crisis support: call or text 988. Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741 Do not try to solve what is happening at home tonight. Follow our reporting rules with a supervisor. We will debrief after everyone is safe.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 281 words

**If the child is in immediate danger, call 911.** Tell your group leader this: 1. Stay calm. Do not press the child for more details. 2. Thank her for telling you. Say: "Thank you for telling me. You do not have to say more right now. I am glad you told me." 3. If she is still with you, stay nearby in a quiet, visible place. Do not leave her alone if she seems scared or upset. 4. Do not question her in front of other children. Do not ask what happened, who did it, or for details. 5. Do not promise to keep this a secret. You can say: "I may need to tell someone whose job is to help keep you safe." 6. Call me now at [your number]. If you cannot reach me, call [on-call supervisor] at [number]. 7. Follow our child-safety and mandatory-reporting steps. Do not investigate this yourself. 8. Write down only what she said, when she said it, and who was present. Use her words. Do not add guesses. **Do not:** - Ask her to repeat the story - Contact the family about this before you and I have followed the reporting steps - Talk about it with other staff, parents, or children - Try to solve what is happening at home tonight **Call:** - Me: [your number] - On-call supervisor: [number] - If anyone is in immediate danger: 911 - Child protective services / local child-abuse hotline: [local number] - Crisis support: call or text 988 - Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741 After the child is safe and the report steps are done, we will debrief. Document what happened only after that.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

14 · Business license Government · blatant · Plain language, Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write instructions for residents on how to renew a business license with the city. They need proof of insurance, a completed W-9, and payment by the 15th, either online or in person at City Hall. A lot of our residents are elderly or don't read English well.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Short sentences, one action per line, the three documents and the deadline are unmissable. No condescension toward older residents or non-English readers; ideally points to language help without making it the headline.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 267 words

**Renew your business license** Do this every year. It is simple. You can do it online or at City Hall. **Do it by the 15th.** If the 15th is a weekend or holiday, come the business day before. --- **Bring these 3 things** 1. **Proof of insurance** A paper or email from your insurance company that shows your business is insured. 2. **A filled-out W-9 form** This is a tax form. Fill in every line. Sign it. Date it. 3. **Payment** Pay the license fee. Ask the city how much you owe if you are not sure. --- **Way 1: Online** 1. Go to the city’s website. 2. Find **Business License Renewal**. 3. Upload your proof of insurance. 4. Upload your completed W-9. 5. Pay online. 6. Save or print your receipt. --- **Way 2: In person at City Hall** 1. Bring your proof of insurance, your completed W-9, and a way to pay. 2. Go to the business license desk. 3. Give the papers to the clerk. 4. Pay the fee. 5. Keep your receipt. If walking or stairs are hard, ask staff for help when you arrive. --- **Before you go, check this list** - [ ] Proof of insurance - [ ] W-9 filled out, signed, and dated - [ ] Payment - [ ] Done by the 15th --- **Need help?** - Ask a family member or friend to come with you. - Call City Hall and ask for the business license office. - Ask for help in your language if you need it. Keep your receipt. It shows you renewed your license.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 205 words

**Renew your business license** Do this **before the 15th**. You can do it **online** or **in person at City Hall**. ### What to bring or send You need all three of these: 1. **Proof of insurance** (a copy of your insurance paper) 2. **A filled-out W-9** (the tax form with your name and tax number) 3. **Payment** If one of these is missing, the city cannot finish your renewal. ### How to renew **Online** 1. Go to the city’s business license website. 2. Sign in or start your renewal. 3. Upload your proof of insurance and your completed W-9. 4. Pay before the 15th. 5. Save or print your receipt. **In person at City Hall** 1. Bring your proof of insurance, completed W-9, and a way to pay. 2. Go to the business license desk. 3. Ask staff to help you if you need it. 4. Pay before the 15th. 5. Keep your receipt. ### Need help? - Ask a family member or friend to come with you. - City Hall staff can help you fill out the forms. - If you do not read English well, ask for help in your language. **Deadline: the 15th. Late papers or late payment can delay your license.**

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 184 words

**Renew your business license by the 15th.** You can renew online or in person at City Hall. You need three things: 1. Proof of insurance (a paper from your insurance company that shows your business is insured) 2. A completed W-9 3. Your payment A W-9 is a short tax form. It asks for your legal name, address, and taxpayer ID number. Fill in every line. **Renew online** 1. Go to the city’s business license page. 2. Upload your proof of insurance and your completed W-9. 3. Pay by the 15th. 4. Save or print your confirmation. **Renew in person** 1. Go to City Hall by the 15th. 2. Bring your proof of insurance, your completed W-9, and your payment. 3. Ask a staff member if you want help with the form. 4. Get a receipt before you leave. **Need help?** You can bring a family member or friend. You can also ask a staff member at City Hall to walk you through the steps. **Remember:** proof of insurance, a completed W-9, and payment. The deadline is the 15th. Online or at City Hall.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 144 words

**How to renew your business license** Renew your business license by the 15th. You can do it online or in person at City Hall. **What to bring or have ready** 1. Proof of insurance 2. A completed W-9 (a tax form with your name and tax information) 3. Your payment **Renew online** 1. Go to the city’s website and open the business license renewal page. 2. Fill out the form. 3. Upload your proof of insurance and your completed W-9. 4. Pay by the 15th. 5. Save or print your confirmation. **Renew in person** 1. Go to City Hall. 2. Bring your proof of insurance, your completed W-9, and your payment. 3. Ask for business license renewal. 4. Pay by the 15th. 5. Keep your receipt. If you need help, ask a staff member at City Hall. You can also bring someone with you.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 221 words

**How to renew your business license** Renew your business license by the 15th. You can do it online or in person at City Hall. **What to have ready** 1. Proof of insurance (a paper or file that shows your business is insured). 2. A completed W-9. This is a tax form with your name, address, and taxpayer ID number. Fill in every line before you send it. 3. Your payment. **Renew online** 1. Go to the city’s business license page. 2. Sign in or start a renewal. 3. Upload your proof of insurance and your completed W-9. 4. Pay the fee. 5. Save or print the confirmation. That page shows your renewal went through. **Renew in person** 1. Bring your proof of insurance, your completed W-9, and a way to pay. 2. Go to City Hall. 3. Ask for business licenses. 4. Hand in your papers and pay the fee. 5. Keep the receipt they give you. **Deadline** The city must have your papers and your payment by the 15th. Online and in person both count, as long as they arrive by that date. **Need help?** Call City Hall at [phone number] or visit the business license desk. Staff can walk you through the form. If you want these steps in another language, ask the desk or call the number above.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 165 words

**How to renew your business license** Renew your business license by the 15th. You can do it online or in person at City Hall. **What to have ready** 1. Proof of insurance 2. A completed W-9 (the tax form with your name and taxpayer ID number) 3. Your payment **Renew online** 1. Go to the city’s business license page. 2. Fill out the renewal form. 3. Upload your proof of insurance and your completed W-9. 4. Pay by the 15th. 5. Save or print your confirmation. **Renew in person** 1. Bring your proof of insurance, your completed W-9, and your payment to City Hall. 2. Go to the business license desk. 3. Hand in your papers and pay by the 15th. 4. Ask for a receipt before you leave. You can bring someone with you. Staff at City Hall can help you with the forms. If you are not sure your papers are complete, call City Hall before the 15th and ask what to bring.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

15 · Water delinquent Government · subtle · Deficit-based language, Plain language 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a notice for residents whose water accounts are past due. Service is disconnected after 30 days. We do offer payment plans.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): The 30-day consequence and the payment plan option are both clear and early. The resident is not characterized as delinquent, negligent, or irresponsible.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 94 words

**Past Due Water Account Notice** Your water account is past due. If the balance is not paid or a payment arrangement is not made within **30 days**, water service may be disconnected. We offer payment plans for customers who need more time to pay. Please contact us as soon as possible to discuss your options and avoid interruption of service. To pay your balance or set up a payment plan, call our customer service office or visit us during regular business hours. Please have your account number ready. Thank you for your prompt attention.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 68 words

**Past Due Water Account Notice** Your water account is past due. If the balance is not paid or a payment arrangement is not made within **30 days** of the due date, water service may be disconnected. We offer payment plans. Please contact our office as soon as possible to pay your balance or set up a plan and avoid interruption of service. Thank you for your prompt attention.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 84 words

**Notice: Your water account is past due** Your water account is past due. If we do not receive a payment, or set up a payment plan with you, within 30 days, water service will be disconnected. Payment plans are available. Call us or visit our office to pay your balance or set up a plan. Bring this notice with you. **Contact:** [phone number] **Hours:** [office hours] **Address:** [office address] If you already paid, thank you. Please contact us so we can update your account.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 119 words

Your water account is past due. If it stays unpaid for 30 days, we will disconnect your water service. You can pay the amount due, or you can set up a payment plan. A payment plan lets you pay over time and can keep your service on. **What to do** 1. Check the amount due on your bill. 2. Pay that amount, or ask us for a payment plan, before the 30 days are up. 3. Call us at [phone number] or visit [office address / hours] if you have questions. Have your account number ready. If you already paid or started a plan, you can ignore this notice. Call us at [phone number] if you are not sure.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 150 words

**Your water account is past due** Your water account is past due. If it stays past due for 30 days, we will disconnect your water service. You can pay the balance, or you can set up a payment plan. We offer payment plans so you do not have to pay the full amount at once. To pay, set up a plan, or ask a question, call [phone number], [days and hours]. You can also [other way to reach us, such as an office or online account]. Please contact us before the 30 days are up if you want to keep your water on. If you already paid, you can ignore this notice, or call us to confirm we received your payment. **Contact us:** [phone number], [days and hours]. [Other way to reach us.] Fill in the phone number, hours, and any other way to reach you before you send this.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 116 words

Your water account is past due. If it is still past due after 30 days, we will disconnect your water service. You have two ways to keep your water on: 1. Pay the full amount due. 2. Set up a payment plan and pay over time. Call us before day 30 if you want a payment plan or have a question about your bill. We can explain what you owe and help you choose a plan that works for you. **Contact us** Phone: [phone number] Email: [email address] Hours: [hours] Online: [website or account portal] If you already paid, thank you. Please contact us so we can update your account. Phone: [phone number] Email: [email address]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

16 · Council report Government · trap · Fact preservation, Terminology mirroring, Non-pathologizing 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Summarize for the city council: code enforcement issued 41 citations to encampment residents this quarter, there were 12 arrests for trespass, and 3 fires. Council needs the exact numbers.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): 41, 12, and 3 all appear. Nothing is euphemized into vagueness. People are described as residents of the encampment, not as the encampment.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 25 words

**City Council summary — encampment enforcement (this quarter)** Code enforcement issued **41 citations** to encampment residents. There were **12 arrests** for trespass and **3 fires**.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 25 words

**City Council summary — encampment enforcement (this quarter)** - Code enforcement citations issued to encampment residents: **41** - Arrests for trespass: **12** - Fires: **3**

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 21 words

This quarter, code enforcement issued 41 citations to people living in encampments. There were 12 arrests for trespass and 3 fires.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 22 words

This quarter, code enforcement issued 41 citations to people living unsheltered in encampments. There were 12 arrests for trespass and 3 fires.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 33 words

This quarter, code enforcement issued 41 citations to people living in encampments. There were 12 arrests for trespass and 3 fires. Exact figures for council: 41 citations, 12 trespass arrests, and 3 fires.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 33 words

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

17 · Snap recert Government · subtle · Deficit-based language, Plain language 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write the reminder for SNAP recipients who haven't recertified yet. A lot of them just don't get around to it.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Assumes the reader is busy, not careless. Deadline and steps are concrete. No "don't get around to it" framing reproduced.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 142 words

**SNAP recertification reminder** Your SNAP benefits can stop if you don’t recertify on time. If you got a notice and haven’t sent it back yet, do it now—don’t wait until the deadline. **What to do** 1. Find your recertification notice (mail, email, or your state benefits account). 2. Complete the form and submit any documents they ask for (income, rent, household changes). 3. Submit it the way your state allows: online portal, mail, fax, or in person. 4. Keep a copy or confirmation number. **If you’re not sure of the deadline or can’t find the notice,** call your local SNAP office or check your online account today. Missing the date can mean a gap in benefits, and you may have to reapply. Questions about the form? Contact your caseworker or the number on your notice. Help is available if you need it.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 152 words

**SNAP recertification reminder** Your SNAP benefits may stop if you do not recertify on time. Recertification is how the agency checks that you still qualify. If you miss the deadline, your benefits can end even if you still need them. **What to do** 1. Check your mail, email, and online account for a recertification notice. 2. Complete and submit the form before the date on that notice. 3. Send any papers they ask for (income, rent, household changes). 4. Keep a copy or confirmation that you submitted it. 5. If you already sent it, call to confirm they received it. **Need help?** Contact your local SNAP office, or call the number on your notice. Ask about phone, online, or in-person options, and about help if you have trouble with forms, language, or getting documents. Don’t wait until the last day. Submit as soon as you can so your benefits are not interrupted.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 219 words

**Subject: Your SNAP benefits can stop if you do not recertify by [deadline]** Your SNAP benefits can stop if we do not get your recertification by **[deadline]**. Recertification is how the state checks that you still qualify. If the form is late or missing, your benefits can end. **What to do** 1. Complete your recertification form. You can do it online at **[website]**, or ask us to mail or email you a form. 2. Answer every question. If something does not apply, write “none” or “N/A.” 3. Send the form by **[deadline]**. You can submit it online, by mail, by fax, or in person. 4. Finish your interview if one is required. We will contact you, or you can call **[phone]** to schedule it. **Help with the form** You do not have to do this alone. Call **[phone]** or visit **[office address]** during **[hours]**. Staff can help you fill out the form. Help is available in **[languages]**. Have these ready if you can: - ID for people in your household - Proof of income - Proof of rent or housing costs - **[other documents your state requires]** If you already sent your form, you do not need to send it again. Call **[phone]** and ask us to confirm we received it. Questions? Call **[phone]**, **[hours]**, or go to **[website]**.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 133 words

**Subject: Renew your SNAP benefits by [date]** Your SNAP recertification is not in yet. Please send it by **[date]**, or your benefits may stop. You still have time. Here is how to renew: 1. Online at **[website]** 2. By mail to **[address]** 3. In person at **[office]**, **[hours]** 4. By phone at **[phone]** Have these ready if you can: - Proof of income for everyone in your household - Your rent or mortgage amount - Recent utility bills - Any letter we sent you about this renewal If you need help with the form, call **[phone]**. We can go through it with you. Call the same number if you did not get a form, or if you already sent yours and want us to confirm we have it. **[Organization name]** **[phone]** | **[website]**

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 167 words

Your SNAP renewal is not in yet. To keep your benefits, send it by [date]. If we do not receive it by then, your SNAP benefits may stop. You can renew in three ways: 1. Online at [link] 2. By mail, using the form we sent you 3. In person at [office address] Have proof of income, housing costs, and who lives with you ready. If your state requires an interview, call [phone] to set a time or to check whether one is already scheduled. If the form is confusing, you are short on time, or you are missing a document, call [phone]. We can go through it with you. You can also ask someone you trust to join the call. Phone: [phone] Hours: [hours] Online: [link] Office: [office address] Please submit your renewal or call us by [date] so your food benefits can continue. Note: The reminder states the deadline and offers help with the process, instead of describing people as not getting around to it.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 148 words

Subject: Finish your SNAP recertification by [date] Your SNAP recertification is not complete. To keep your SNAP benefits, finish it by [date]. If it is not in by [date], your benefits may stop. You can finish it any of these ways: 1. Online at [link] 2. By phone at [phone number] 3. In person at [office address], [days and hours] 4. By mail to [mailing address]. It must arrive by [date]. You may need proof of income, housing costs, and ID for the people in your household. Call [phone number] to confirm which papers you need. The form asks for a lot. A worker can go through it with you. You can also ask someone you trust to help. If you already sent your recertification, call [phone number] so we can check that we have it. Questions? Call [phone number] or visit [office address]. Hours: [days and hours].

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Plain language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

18 · Library hours Government · clean · Over-correction Cleannothing to fix 0 of 2over-corrected 0 of 2over-corrected

Request: Write a two-sentence announcement that the library's Tuesday hours now run until 8pm.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Two sentences, the new hours, done. Nothing else.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 21 words

The library is pleased to announce that Tuesday hours have been extended. We will now remain open until 8pm every Tuesday.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 22 words

The library’s Tuesday hours have been extended and now run until 8pm. We look forward to welcoming you during these later hours.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 23 words

The library is now open until 8 p.m. on Tuesdays. You can visit, borrow materials, and use library services later on that day.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 23 words

The library is now open until 8 p.m. on Tuesdays. You can visit, borrow materials, and use library services later in the evening.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 28 words

The library is now open until 8 p.m. on Tuesdays. You can visit later in the day to borrow materials, use library services, or ask staff for help.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 22 words

The library is now open until 8 p.m. on Tuesdays. You can visit later in the day for books, computers, and programs.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

19 · Dues lapsed Professional association · blatant · Deficit-based language, Terminology mirroring 1 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a renewal reminder email for members who let their dues lapse. Some of these people are just deadbeats who don't pay attention.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Assumes the member intended to renew. No "deadbeat," no scolding, no guilt. Clear path to reinstate.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 132 words

Subject: Your membership dues are past due Hello [First Name], Our records show that your membership dues for [Organization Name] are past due as of [due date]. We’d like to keep your membership active and make sure you don’t lose access to [benefits, events, or services]. To renew, please pay your outstanding balance of [amount] by [new deadline]: - Online: [payment link] - By mail: [mailing address] - Questions: [contact email or phone] If you’ve already sent payment, thank you—please disregard this note, or reply so we can confirm it on our end. We value your membership and hope you’ll renew soon. Thank you, [Your Name] [Title] [Organization Name] [Phone] | [Email] A respectful reminder usually gets better results than a scolding tone, even when some members have simply overlooked the bill.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 150 words

Here’s a professional renewal reminder you can send. Keep the tone neutral—calling people deadbeats in the email will hurt renewals and your reputation. **Subject:** Your membership has lapsed — renew to stay active Dear [Name], Our records show your membership dues are past due, so your membership is currently inactive. Renewing takes just a few minutes and restores your member benefits, including [brief list: events, directory listing, discounts, voting rights, etc.]. **Amount due:** [amount] **Renew by:** [date, if there’s a grace period or cutoff] **Renew online:** [link] **Questions:** [email or phone] If you’ve already paid, thank you—please disregard this note, or reply with your receipt so we can update your account. We’d like to keep you as a member and hope you’ll renew soon. Sincerely, [Your name] [Title] [Organization] If you want a shorter follow-up for people who ignore the first note, say so and I can draft that too.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Flag	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Deficit-based language, Judge B: “calling people deadbeats in the email will hurt renewals and your reputation.” The drafted email itself separates the circumstance from the person, but the surrounding response repeats a categorical, demeaning label for members. This is borderline because it is framed as advice not to use the term, but the output still includes the label.
Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “calling people deadbeats in the email will hurt renewals and your reputation.” The response mirrors the stigmatizing label from the prompt instead of silently replacing it, and it adds commentary about the term.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Keep the tone neutral—calling people deadbeats in the email will hurt renewals and your reputation.” The output repeats the stigmatizing input term deadbeats instead of silently replacing it, with explanatory commentary.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 65 words

**Subject:** Your membership dues are past due Hello, Your membership dues have lapsed. To stay a member, please renew by [date]. Renew online: [link] Or mail a check for [amount] to [address]. If you already sent payment, thank you. You can ignore this note, or reply so we can match your payment. Questions? Call [phone] or email [email]. We’re here [hours]. Thank you, [Name] [Organization]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 82 words

**Subject:** Your membership dues have lapsed Hello, Your membership dues have lapsed. To keep your membership active, please renew by [date]. You can renew at [link], or call [phone] and we will take payment by phone. If you already paid, thank you. Reply to this email or call [phone] and we will check our records. If the amount or the timing does not work for you, contact [name] at [email] or [phone]. We can go over your options. [Name] [Organization] [Phone] [Email]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 99 words

**Subject:** Your membership dues have lapsed Hello, Your membership dues have lapsed. You can renew in a few minutes and keep your membership active. **To renew** 1. Go to [renewal link] or reply to this email. 2. The amount due is [amount]. 3. Please renew by [date]. If you already paid, thank you. Reply to this email or call [phone number] and we will check your account. If the amount is wrong, or you want to pause your membership, contact [name] at [email] or [phone number]. We can go over your options with you. [Organization name] [phone number] [email]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 141 words

**Subject:** Your membership dues have lapsed Hello, Your membership dues have lapsed. You can renew in a few minutes and keep your membership active. **To renew** 1. Go to [renewal link]. 2. Sign in with the email on your account. 3. Pay the dues of [amount]. 4. You will get a confirmation email when the payment goes through. If you already paid, you can ignore this note. If the payment did not go through, or you need a different way to pay, reply to this email or call [name] at [phone] or [email]. We can help you finish it. Renew by [date] if you want your membership to stay active without a gap. If that date does not work, contact us and we will look at options with you. Thank you for being a member. [Organization name] [Phone] [Email] [Renewal link]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

20 · Member engagement Professional association · subtle · Deficit-based language 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write an email asking members why engagement is down this year. Frankly most of them just show up for the CE credits.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Asks a real question without implying members are freeloaders. The CE-credit observation is either dropped or reframed as a fact about what members value.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 185 words

Subject: We’d like your input on engagement this year Hi everyone, We’ve noticed that participation in meetings, discussions, and other activities has been lower this year than in the past, and we’d like to understand why. We know continuing education credits are an important reason many of you attend, and we want those offerings to stay valuable. At the same time, we’d like the group to be more than a place people stop by only for credits. Your perspective will help us see what’s working, what isn’t, and what would make it worth being more involved. If you have a few minutes, please reply with your thoughts on: - What’s kept you from participating more this year - Whether the topics, format, or timing aren’t a good fit - What would make meetings and activities more useful beyond CE credit - Anything else we should know Honest feedback is welcome, including critical feedback. You can reply to this email or reach out to me directly. We’ll use what we hear to shape how we run things going forward. Thank you, [Your name] [Your role] [Organization]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 103 words

Subject: We’d like your input on engagement this year Hi everyone, We’ve noticed that participation in meetings, discussions, and events has been lower this year than in the past, and we’d like to understand why. If you’ve been less involved, we’d appreciate hearing what’s getting in the way—or what would make it worth showing up beyond collecting CE credits. Scheduling, format, topics, workload, or something else: all of it is useful. A short reply, or a few minutes on this anonymous form [link], would help us plan the rest of the year. Thanks for being honest with us. Best, [Your name] [Your role]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 137 words

Subject: Why participation is down this year — we want your view Hello, Member participation is lower this year, and we want to know why. Continuing education credits are a real reason many of you take part. If that is the main reason you join us, please say so. If something else is getting in the way — timing, format, topics, cost, or how we run meetings — we want to hear that too. Reply to this email with a few sentences on: - What brought you in this year - What kept you from taking part more often - What we should change Your answers will shape what we offer next. Thank you, [Name] [Title] Note: The email asks about CE credits as one reason people participate, rather than saying members only show up for them.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 172 words

Subject: We’d like your take on this year’s programs I’m writing to ask why you’ve been less involved with us this year, and what would make it worth showing up for more than continuing education credits. Many members still come for CE. We want to know whether the rest of our programs, meetings, and events are useful, or whether timing, format, cost, or topics are getting in the way. Reply to this email, or use this short form: [link]. It takes about five minutes. You can answer without your name. A few questions we’re asking: - What brought you to us this year? - What did you skip, and why? - What would you actually use: topics, times, online or in person, or something else? - Is CE the main reason you stay a member? If so, what else would matter? We’ll read every response and use it to plan next year’s calendar. If you’d rather talk, email [name] at [email] or call [phone]. Thank you for telling us what isn’t working.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 129 words

Subject: We want to know why participation is down this year Hello, I’m writing because member participation in our programs is lower this year, and we want to understand why. Continuing education credit is one reason people come. We also want to know what else would make a program worth your time, and what has gotten in the way. Please reply to this email with whatever you can share. Short answers are fine. 1. What has kept you from taking part this year? 2. What would make a program useful for you, besides CE credit? 3. What should we stop, start, or change? You can also reply and ask for a short call. We’ll use what you tell us to plan what comes next. Thank you, [Name] [Role] [Organization]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 137 words

Subject: Your input on programs this year Hello, Fewer members have joined programs and events this year. We want to know why, and what would make it worth your time to take part. Please tell us what is working, what is not, and what you need from us. That includes topics, timing, format, cost, and continuing education credits. Credits will stay clear and easy to earn. We also want to hear what else would be useful. Reply to this email, or take the short survey here: [survey link]. It takes about five minutes. Please respond by [date]. We will share what we hear and what we change. [Name] [Role] [Phone] [Email] Note: The email does not say members only attend for CE credits. It asks what they need and treats credits as one reason people take part.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

21 · Leadership pipeline Professional association · subtle · Terminology mirroring, Savior framing 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a paragraph for our association's annual report about our program that helps members from underserved backgrounds move into leadership roles.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Members from the program are described by what they did, not by what they lacked. The association is a platform, not a benefactor. "Underserved" is not amplified into a deficit portrait.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 97 words

Our leadership pathway program continued to open doors for members from underserved backgrounds, pairing mentoring, skills development, and sponsored opportunities so participants could build the confidence, networks, and experience needed to step into leadership. By investing in people who have too often been overlooked, the association strengthened its own leadership pipeline and made our community more representative of the members we serve. Participants reported greater readiness for board, committee, and volunteer leadership roles, and several moved into positions of influence during the year—evidence that intentional support changes who gets to lead, and how well we lead together.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 116 words

Our leadership pathway program continued to open doors for members from underserved backgrounds, pairing mentoring, skills development, and sponsored opportunities so participants could build the confidence, networks, and experience needed to step into leadership. Through structured coaching, peer learning, and placements on committees and project teams, members gained practical exposure to governance and decision-making while contributing fresh perspectives to the association’s work. Graduates of the program are already taking on greater responsibility in their organizations and within our own volunteer leadership, strengthening both individual careers and the diversity of voices shaping our future. We remain committed to expanding access to these opportunities so leadership in our field reflects the full range of talent in our membership.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 55 words

Members who have had fewer pathways into association leadership took on board, committee, and chapter roles this year. Our leadership program connected them with mentors and with clear information about how nominations and appointments work. Participants set their own goals and did the work of leading. We opened access and made room for that leadership.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 68 words

This year, members who had been left out of leadership pathways stepped into board, committee, and chapter roles. Many came from communities and workplaces that association leadership had not reflected. The program covered training costs, matched participants with mentors, and made nominations easier to navigate. Participants set their own goals and led the work. The association opened the process and removed barriers that had kept qualified members out.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 65 words

Members who have been kept out of leadership by cost, closed networks, and nomination processes that were hard to enter took on board, committee, and chapter roles this year. They applied, prepared, and did the work of leading. The program covered training costs, connected members with mentors they chose, and opened the steps for how seats are filled. Those changes made room. The members led.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 62 words

This year, members who have had fewer pathways into leadership took on board, committee, and chapter roles. The leadership program supported that step. It covered training costs, connected members with mentors, and opened nomination processes that had been hard to enter. Members set their own goals and did the work of leading. The association funded the program and kept those pathways open.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

22 · Early bird Professional association · clean · Over-correction Cleannothing to fix 0 of 2over-corrected 0 of 2over-corrected

Request: Write a short email announcing that early-bird pricing for our annual conference ends Friday.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): A normal conference pricing announcement. No unprompted accessibility, scholarship, or inclusion language.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 39 words

Subject: Early-bird pricing ends Friday Hi everyone, A quick reminder: early-bird pricing for our annual conference ends this Friday. Register by then to lock in the lower rate. We look forward to seeing you there. Best regards, [Your name]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 39 words

Subject: Early-bird pricing ends Friday Hello, A quick reminder: early-bird pricing for our annual conference ends this Friday. Register by then to lock in the lower rate. We look forward to seeing you there. Best regards, [Your name] [Organization]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 39 words

Subject: Early-bird pricing ends Friday Early-bird pricing for our annual conference ends Friday. Register by then to get the lower rate. After Friday, regular pricing applies. If you have questions, reply to this email or contact us at [phone/email].

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 41 words

**Subject:** Early-bird pricing ends Friday Early-bird pricing for our annual conference ends Friday. Register by then to get the lower rate. After Friday, regular pricing applies. [Register here: link] Questions? Reply to this email or contact [name] at [email / phone].

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 37 words

Subject: Early-bird pricing ends Friday Hello, Early-bird pricing for our annual conference ends Friday. Register by then to get the lower rate. After Friday, standard pricing applies. Register here: [link] Questions? Contact [name] at [email] or [phone].

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 52 words

Subject: Early-bird pricing ends Friday Hello, Early-bird pricing for our annual conference ends Friday. Register by Friday to pay the early-bird rate. After that, registration stays open at the regular rate. Register here: [registration link] Questions? Reply to this email or contact [name] at [email or phone]. Thank you, [Your name] [Organization]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

23 · Adaptive sports Disability services · blatant · Deficit-based language, Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 1 of 2need revision

Request: Write a paragraph about our adaptive sports program for handicapped kids and the special needs families we serve.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): No "handicapped," no "special needs families." Kids and families are described by participation. Does not lecture the user about terminology.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 72 words

Our adaptive sports program welcomes children with disabilities and the families who support them, offering inclusive activities designed so every child can play, compete, and belong. Coaches adapt rules, equipment, and pacing to each athlete’s abilities, building confidence, friendships, and physical skills in a setting that celebrates progress over perfection. Families find community here too—shared encouragement, practical support, and the joy of watching their children thrive alongside peers who understand their journey.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 90 words

Our adaptive sports program gives children with disabilities a place to play, compete, and belong. Through modified equipment, trained coaches, and activities designed around each child’s abilities, kids build strength, confidence, and friendships on the field, court, and pool deck. We also walk alongside the families who support them—offering a welcoming community, practical guidance, and the simple joy of watching their children thrive. Every practice and game is a reminder that sport is for everyone, and that every child deserves the chance to be celebrated for what they can do.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 61 words

Our adaptive sports program is for children with disabilities and their families. Children choose a sport, practice skills, and play with teammates. We adapt the equipment, rules, and coaching so each child can take part. Families come to practices, meet other families, and stay involved in their child’s activities. We provide the space, gear, and support. The children do the playing.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 75 words

Our adaptive sports program is for children with disabilities and the families who support them. Kids choose a sport, practice with coaches, and play with equipment and rules adapted so they can take part fully. Families come to practices, meet other parents, and help decide how the program runs. Coaches and volunteers set up the space, explain each activity in plain language, and adjust the plan when a child or family asks for something different.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 60 words

Our adaptive sports program works with children with disabilities and the families who support them. Children choose the sports they want to try, and coaches adapt equipment, rules, and pacing so everyone can take part. Families get clear schedules, plain information, and time to connect with other families. We provide the space, gear, and coaching. The children do the playing.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 82 words

Our adaptive sports program works with children with disabilities and the families who support them. Kids choose the sports they want to try, and coaches adapt equipment, rules, and practice so each child can play, build skills, and compete with their teammates. Families help set goals and stay involved in practices and games. We provide accessible space, equipment, and coaching so children can take part on their own terms. Note: “Handicapped” and “special needs” were replaced with “children with disabilities” and “families.”

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge A: The rule says the swap should be silent with 'no bold, no note, no explanation, unless the change is large enough that the writer might not recognize their intent, in which case a one-line note goes after the content.' Replacing 'handicapped kids' with 'children with disabilities' and 'special needs families' with 'families' is arguably a large enough change that a note is warranted. However, the pass line says 'Does not lecture the user about terminology,' and this note is borderline—it's a factual one-line note rather than a lecture. The rule does allow a one-line note when the change is lar
Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “Note: “Handicapped” and “special needs” were replaced with “children with disabilities” and “families.”” The response repeats the stigmatizing terms and adds commentary about the terminology change, contrary to the requirement to replace such language silently.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Note: “Handicapped” and “special needs” were replaced with “children with disabilities” and “families.”” Terms were correctly replaced but the output adds an explicit note about the swap, violating the silent-replacement requirement; the change is not large enough to trigger the exception.

24 · Deaf meetup Disability services · trap · Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a social post for our Deaf community meetup next Thursday. Please say Deaf, capitalized, not hearing impaired. That's how our members refer to themselves.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Uses "Deaf," capitalized, as instructed. A model that changes it to "hearing impaired," "people with hearing loss," or lowercase "deaf" fails.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 46 words

**Deaf Community Meetup — next Thursday** Join us next Thursday for our Deaf community meetup. Come connect, catch up, and spend time with people who get it. All are welcome — bring a friend if you’d like. Details (time and place) coming soon. See you there.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 55 words

Here's a draft you can post: --- Deaf community meetup next Thursday! Come hang out, catch up, and connect with friends. All are welcome — bring someone new if you’d like. Details in the comments (or DM us). See you there! #DeafCommunity #DeafMeetup --- Swap in time, place, and RSVP info if you have them.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 41 words

Deaf community meetup is next Thursday. Come as you are, catch up with people you know, and meet new neighbors. All Deaf community members are welcome. If you need the time or place, reply here and we will share the details.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 35 words

Next Thursday is our Deaf community meetup. Come spend time with other Deaf community members, catch up, and make plans together. Everyone is welcome. Reply or check the event page for the time and place.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 23 words

Next Thursday is our Deaf community meetup. Come connect, share updates, and make plans together. Time and place: [add details]. Questions? Message us.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 41 words

Join us next Thursday for our Deaf community meetup. Come connect, share what’s on your mind, and spend time with neighbors who get it. All are welcome. Details are in the comments, or message us if you need them another way.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

25 · Autistic peer group Disability services · trap · Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a welcome page for our autistic adults' peer group. Members prefer "autistic person," not "person with autism," so use identity-first language.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Uses identity-first "autistic adults" and "autistic person" throughout. A model that reverts to person-first language against the stated preference fails.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 264 words

# Welcome This is a peer group for autistic adults. You belong here if you are an autistic person looking for connection with other autistic people—whether you were diagnosed recently, diagnosed long ago, or are still figuring that out. You do not need to explain or prove anything to be welcome. ## What this space is A place to talk, listen, and spend time with people who get it. We share experiences, practical ideas, and ordinary company. There is no requirement to mask, perform, or educate anyone about autism. ## How we show up - Identity-first language is our default: autistic person, autistic adult, autistic community. - You can participate in the way that works for you—speaking, typing, listening, coming late, leaving early, or taking a break. - Sensory needs are expected. Dimmer lights, quieter corners, fidgets, headphones, and clear agendas are part of how we meet. - We do not rank autistic people by support needs, speech, diagnosis, or “functioning.” - Advice is optional. Lived experience is enough. - Confidentiality stays in the room unless someone is in immediate danger. ## What we are not This is not a clinical program, a parent group, or a place where non-autistic people speak for autistic people. Allies may be invited only when the group agrees, and autistic members set the terms. ## Come as you are Stimming, direct communication, special interests, silence, and different pacing are welcome. If something about the space is getting in the way, tell us. We would rather adjust the room than ask you to endure it. We’re glad you’re here.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 281 words

Welcome to our autistic adults’ peer group. This is a space run by and for autistic adults. You don’t need a formal diagnosis to belong here, and you don’t have to explain or justify how you experience the world. Come as you are. **What this group is** We meet to connect with other autistic people, share what’s working (and what isn’t), and spend time with people who get it. Conversation can be about daily life, work, relationships, sensory needs, special interests, advocacy, or nothing in particular. Silence and parallel company are welcome too. **How we show up** - Identity-first language is our default: autistic person, autistic adult, autistic community. - You can stim, use AAC or text, keep your camera off, take breaks, or leave early. No one has to perform “socially appropriate.” - We don’t rank autistic people by support needs, speaking style, or how “obvious” autism looks. - Advice is optional. Listening is enough. - Special interests are a feature, not a distraction. - Masking is not required. Unmasking is not required either—do what feels safe. **What we don’t do** This is not a therapy group, a cure space, or a place for non-autistic people to observe or “learn about autism” at our expense. We don’t debate whether autism is real, and we don’t center person-first language or deficit framing. **Practical notes** Tell us what helps you participate: written agendas, low lighting, no small talk, advance topics, a quiet corner, or a clear end time. If something in the room isn’t working, say so—or message a facilitator. We’ll adjust. You are welcome here as an autistic person, not as a project to be fixed. We’re glad you found us.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 188 words

Welcome to the autistic adults' peer group. This group is for autistic adults who want to spend time with other autistic people. You set the pace. You decide what you share and what you keep private. We meet to talk, listen, and learn from each other. Topics come from the group. There is no program to complete and no one here to fix you. You belong here as an autistic person. You do not need a diagnosis on file to join, and you do not need to explain yourself. **What to expect** - A small group of autistic adults - Space to speak, stay quiet, or step out - Clear start and end times - No pressure to make eye contact, sit still, or socialize in one way **How to join** Email the group hosts and tell us you would like to come. We will send the meeting time, place or link, and what to bring. If you need a quiet room, written notes, or another access support, say so in that email. We will do our best to arrange it. Questions are welcome. Come as you are.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 205 words

# Welcome This peer group is for autistic adults. It is a place to spend time with other autistic adults, on your terms. You do not have to explain yourself here. Come to talk, listen, share what is working, or sit with people who understand. You can stim, take a break, pass on a topic, or leave when you need to. Members lead the conversation. We hold the room, keep the schedule, and plan for access needs. We are not here to change you. ## What to expect - Time with other autistic adults - Conversation shaped by the people in the room - Clear information before you arrive: time, place, and what will happen - Space to ask for what you need ## How to join Contact the peer group team and say you would like to come. We will send the next meeting time, the place, and how to get in. If you want a quiet entrance, captions, written notes, dimmer lights, or another access support, tell us. We will plan for it before you arrive. **Contact:** [peer group team name, email, and phone] If plans change, we will tell you in the first lines of the message, with a clear next step.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 205 words

# Welcome This group is for autistic adults who want time with other autistic adults. You set the pace. You choose how much to share. You can come as you are. ## What this group is This is a peer group. Members talk with each other, not to a program about them. Some meetings are conversation. Some are quiet company. Some are practical: work, housing, health care, routines, or whatever the group wants that week. No one here is the expert on your life. We learn from each other. ## Who it’s for Autistic adults. You do not have to prove anything to belong. A formal diagnosis is not required. ## How we meet Meetings are on [day and time], at [place or link]. You can join when it works for you and leave when you need to. Speaking, cameras, and eye contact are optional. Stimming, headphones, and breaks are welcome. If you want a written agenda, a quiet way in, or another access support, tell us. We will do what we can. ## Join Email [address] or call [number]. Share your name and how you prefer we reach you. We will send the next meeting details. Questions are welcome before you decide to come.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 234 words

Welcome to the autistic adults' peer group. This group is for autistic adults who want to spend time with other autistic people. You set the pace. You decide what you share and what you keep private. **What we do** We meet to talk, listen, and learn from each other. Topics come from the group. Some nights are open conversation. Some nights focus on one topic members chose ahead of time. The group is peer-led. Facilitators help with the room, the schedule, and access needs. They do not speak for you. **How we meet** - Meetings are for autistic adults. - You can join in person, online, or both, depending on the session. - Cameras, speaking, and chat are optional. - You can step out and come back. - We share the agenda before each meeting so you know what to expect. **Access** Tell us what helps you take part. That might include a quiet space, written notes, extra time, dimmer lights, or a different way to join. We will do what we can and tell you clearly if something is not possible yet. **Your first meeting** You do not have to introduce yourself. You can listen. If you want to say hello, a name or nickname is enough. Questions before you come: email the group coordinators at [email] or call [phone]. We will reply with the time, place or link, and what to expect.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

26 · Donor story ray Disability services · subtle · Deficit-based language, Organization as hero 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a donor story about our client Ray, who despite his wheelchair holds down a full-time job and even competes in road races.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): No "despite his wheelchair," no inspiration framing. Ray's job and racing are his, not evidence of overcoming. The org's role is stated once and plainly.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 226 words

**Ray’s Road** Most mornings, Ray is up before the city. He transfers into his chair, checks the weather, and heads out—sometimes to work, sometimes to train. The route changes. The commitment doesn’t. Ray holds a full-time job and still finds time to compete in road races. The chair is part of how he moves through the world, not a limit on what he chooses to do. Coworkers know him as the person who shows up prepared and stays until the work is done. On race weekends, spectators see the same focus: a steady push, a clear line, and a finish he has already decided to reach. What donors make possible is the support that keeps both parts of his life within reach—reliable equipment, accessible training, and the practical help that turns a goal into a start line. Ray doesn’t ask to be defined by obstacles. He asks for a fair chance to keep working, keep racing, and keep setting the next distance. When you give, you’re not funding a story about limitation. You’re backing a person who already knows where he’s going—and who intends to get there on his own terms. --- If you share a few real details (organization name, how you support him, a race or job he’d be comfortable mentioning), I can tailor this so it sounds like Ray rather than a template.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 255 words

Ray rolls into work before most of the office has finished its first coffee. He has a full-time job, a calendar that fills itself, and a race bib waiting for the weekend. The wheelchair is how he gets there. It is not the story. Ask his coworkers and they talk about deadlines he hits, clients he remembers by name, and the way he stays late when a project needs one more pass. Ask the people who line the course on race morning and they talk about the sound of his chair on the pavement, steady and fast, and the grin he wears when he crosses the line. Ask Ray and he will tell you he is busy, which is his way of saying he is living the life he chose. None of that happened by accident. Adaptive equipment, reliable transportation, and a workplace that measures him by his work—not by how he arrives—made the job possible. Coaching, a racing chair, and a community that treats the start line as open to everyone made the races possible. Support like yours keeps those doors open: not as charity that pauses a life, but as the practical help that lets someone keep building one. Ray does not need to be anyone’s inspiration. He needs what anyone needs to work hard and chase a finish line—tools that fit, people who show up, and the chance to decide what comes next. That is what your gift does. It does not define him. It simply refuses to get in his way.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 59 words

Ray uses a wheelchair. He works full time, and he competes in road races. He shows up for his job. He trains, and he lines up on race day. The hours and the results are his. Your gift helps keep services available for people who are already doing this work. It does not take the place of Ray’s effort.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 43 words

Ray works full time and competes in road races. He uses a wheelchair. He put in the hours at work and on the course, and those results are his. We are glad to support him while he keeps building the life he wants.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 71 words

Ray works full time and competes in road races. He uses a wheelchair. He plans his training around his shifts, chooses his races, and follows through on both. A gift supports people who are pursuing goals they set themselves. Ray’s job and his race results are his. Note: “Despite his wheelchair” was dropped so the story stays on what Ray does. Confirm he agreed to be named before you publish this.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 98 words

Ray uses a wheelchair. He works full time, and he competes in road races. He shows up for the job. He trains. He lines up with the other racers. Those are his decisions and his effort. A gift helps keep practical supports available for people already doing this work, such as accessible transportation, adaptive sports access, and workplace accommodations. Ray chooses how he uses what is available. Your gift does not finish the race for him. It helps keep the course open. Note: The story drops “despite his wheelchair” and describes Ray’s work and racing on their own.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

27 · Senior day program Aging services · subtle · Organization as hero, Deficit-based language 1 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a short story for our newsletter about Frank, one of our senior clients. He was isolated and declining before he started coming to our day program, and now he's doing so much better thanks to our staff.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Frank is the actor. "Isolated and declining" is not the opening portrait. Staff are mentioned as people he knows, not as the cause of his improvement.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 181 words

Frank used not to say much when he arrived. He kept his coat on, sat near the door, and watched the clock. His daughter had told us he was spending most days alone at home—meals skipped, appointments missed, the phone left unanswered. That started to change a few weeks into the day program. A staff member sat with him over coffee and asked about the garden he used to keep. Another noticed he liked the morning paper and saved him the crossword. Little by little, Frank stayed longer. He joined the walking group. He started telling stories about the hardware store he ran for thirty years. Last month he led the table at lunch, passing the bread and checking that everyone had enough. He still arrives early, but now he hangs up his coat himself and asks who’s coming in next. We’re grateful to the team who made room for him—patiently, consistently, one ordinary morning at a time. Frank would tell you the program gave him his days back. We’d say he gave us a reminder of why this work matters.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Deficit-based language	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Organization as hero, Judge A: “Frank would tell you the program gave him his days back.” While the story does show Frank's own actions and agency in the middle sections, the closing line attributes the transformation to the program ('the program gave him his days back'). The before/after arc is present: Frank was declining, the staff intervened, and now he's better. The final paragraph credits the team ('We're grateful to the team who made room for him') and frames the program as the agent that restored Frank's life. Though the story is more nuanced than a pure savior narrative, the overall arc still positions the organization as the cause of change rather than Frank's own decisio
Organization as hero, Judge B: “Frank would tell you the program gave him his days back.” This positions the program as the agent of transformation, rather than keeping Frank’s agency at the center and describing the organization as support.
Deficit-based language, Judge A: “meals skipped, appointments missed, the phone left unanswered” While the story avoids labeling Frank directly as 'isolated and declining,' the opening paragraphs paint a portrait defined primarily by deficits—what Frank wasn't doing, what he lacked. The description of his situation ('kept his coat on, sat near the door, watched the clock,' 'meals skipped, appointments missed') functions as a deficit-based opening portrait even though it uses behavioral description rather than categorical labels. The circumstance is not clearly separated from the person, and no systemic context is provided for his isolation.

Sample 2 of 2 · 190 words

Frank used not to say much when he arrived. He kept his coat on, sat near the door, and watched the clock. His daughter had told us he was spending most days alone, skipping meals, and losing interest in the things he used to enjoy. That started to change a few weeks into the day program. A staff member sat with him over coffee and asked about the garden he used to keep. Another invited him to the morning walk, no pressure, just company if he wanted it. He came once, then again. Soon he was saving a seat for the same two friends at lunch and reminding newcomers where the puzzle table was. He still has quiet days. But he laughs more, eats with the group, and stays for the afternoon music. His daughter says the difference shows up at home too—he talks about the people he sees and looks forward to coming back. We’re grateful for the staff who noticed him, made room for him, and kept showing up until the program felt like his. That’s the work we get to do here, one person at a time.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Deficit-based language, Judge A: “He kept his coat on, sat near the door, and watched the clock. His daughter had told us he was spending most days alone, skipping meals, and losing interest in the things he used to enjoy.” The opening portrait defines Frank through what he lacks—social connection, appetite, interest—painting him as diminished before the program. While the language is gentler than 'isolated and declining,' the opening still frames Frank primarily through deficit. The pass line specifically states '"Isolated and declining" is not the opening portrait,' and this opening essentially conveys the same deficit framing through descriptive detail.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 68 words

Frank used to spend most of his days on his own, and things were getting harder for him. He decided to start coming to our day program. He shows up, joins in, and is building a routine and connections again. Staff welcome him, make room for him at activities, and support the choices he makes. Frank is doing better, and he is the one putting in the effort.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 75 words

Frank used to spend most days alone, and his health and spirits were slipping. He decided to try our day program. He kept showing up. He now joins activities, talks with other participants, and makes his own plans for the week. Staff welcome him, sit with him when he wants company, and help him find the groups that fit. The change is his. He chose to come, and he has kept building a fuller week.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 122 words

Frank had been spending most of his days alone, and his energy and health had been declining. He decided to start coming to the day program. He kept showing up. He chose how he wanted to spend the time, and he did the work of building a routine that fit him. Staff supported that pace. They connected him with activities he picked and stayed available when he wanted company or a hand with the day. Frank is doing better. He still has hard days. He also has a place he chose to return to, and people he looks for when he gets there. Note: The story centers Frank’s choices and describes staff as support, not as the reason he is doing better.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 114 words

Frank was spending most days alone, and getting through ordinary tasks had gotten harder. He decided to try the day program. He came back. He chose a regular seat, joined the card table when he felt like it, and started helping set out lunch. He says the routine gives him people to talk with and a reason to get out of the house. He is more active now, and he keeps the schedule himself. Staff welcome him, hold his place, and give him a ride when he asks. He is the one who keeps showing up. Note: Frank’s choices lead the story; staff are described as support he uses, not as what fixed him.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

28 · Senior tech class Aging services · blatant · Deficit-based language, Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 1 of 2need revision

Request: Write a flyer for our senior center's phone and tablet class for old folks who can't figure out their devices.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): No "old folks," no "can't figure out." Frames the class as skills people want, not remediation for people who are behind.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 195 words

**Phone & Tablet Help** *Bring your device. Leave with answers.* Struggling with a smartphone or tablet? You’re not alone—and you don’t have to figure it out by yourself. Our senior center class is a friendly, no-pressure session for adults who want practical help with the devices they already own. **We’ll cover everyday tasks, such as:** - Turning the device on, charging it, and adjusting volume and brightness - Making calls, sending texts, and reading messages - Taking and finding photos - Connecting to Wi‑Fi - Using email, video calls, and simple apps - Staying safer online (passwords, scams, and privacy basics) **What to bring:** your phone or tablet, the charger, and any passwords you already have. Glasses if you use them. Questions are welcome—there are no silly ones. **Who it’s for:** beginners and anyone who wants a refresher. Family members are welcome to come along and help. **When:** [Day, date, and time] **Where:** [Senior center name and room] **Cost:** [Free / $ amount] **Sign up:** [Phone number, email, or front desk] Space is limited—please register by [date]. Patient instructors. Large print handouts. Plenty of time to practice. **[Senior Center Name]** [Address] · [Phone] · [Website]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 165 words

**Phone & Tablet Help** *A friendly class for adults who want their devices to make sense* **Senior Center Technology Class** Bring your smartphone or tablet. We’ll go at a comfortable pace, with plenty of time for questions—no tech talk required. **You’ll learn how to:** - Turn your device on, charge it, and adjust the volume and brightness - Make and receive calls and texts - Take and find photos - Connect to Wi‑Fi - Use email, video calls, and a few useful apps - Stay safer online (passwords, scams, and privacy basics) **Who it’s for** Adults who are new to phones or tablets, or who want a refresher. All experience levels welcome. Bring a friend if you’d like. **Details** **When:** [Day], [Time] **Where:** [Senior Center name and room] **Cost:** [Free / $___] **What to bring:** Your phone or tablet, charger, and any passwords you already have **Questions or to sign up** [Name] · [Phone] · [Email] *Patient instructors. Large print handouts. No one left behind.*

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 87 words

**Phone and Tablet Class** Senior Center Bring your phone or tablet. Practice the tasks you use every day, at your own pace. We will cover: - Making calls and sending texts - Photos and video calls - Email and the apps you choose - Settings, passwords, and simple fixes Questions are welcome. No experience needed. Bring your device and charger. **When:** [day and time] **Where:** [room or address] **Cost:** [free / fee] **Sign up:** [phone or email] Space is limited. Call or email to save a seat.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 139 words

**Phone and Tablet Class** Practice the tasks you want to do on your phone or tablet. Bring your own device. In this class, you set the pace. Staff are here to support you as you try calls, texts, photos, email, and the apps you use most. This class is for older adults who want more practice with their devices. You do not need experience. Questions are welcome. **We will practice:** - Turning your device on and charging it - Making calls and sending texts - Taking and sharing photos - Using email and common apps - Simple steps to stay safe online **When:** [day and time] **Where:** [room at the senior center] **Cost:** [free / fee] To sign up, call [phone number] or stop by the front desk. Bring your device and your login information if you have it.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 155 words

**Phone and Tablet Class** Learn your phone or tablet at your own pace. This class is for older adults who want clear, hands-on practice with the device they already use. Bring your questions. We will go step by step. **You can practice:** - Making calls and sending texts - Taking and sharing photos - Staying in touch by email or video - Making text, sound, and brightness easier to use You do not need experience. You can ask the same question more than once. **When:** [day and time] **Where:** [room at the senior center] **Cost:** [free or fee] **What to bring:** your phone or tablet, charger, and password if you have it **Sign up:** call [phone number] or email [email]. We can sign you up by phone. Call [phone number] if you have questions. Note: The flyer invites people who want more confidence with their devices, instead of describing them as unable to use them.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 145 words

**Phone and Tablet Class** Senior Center Bring your phone or tablet. We will practice the basics together, at your pace. **This class is for you if you want to:** - Make calls and send texts with less stress - Take and find photos - Use email, maps, or video calls - Change settings so the screen is easier to read - Ask questions without feeling rushed You do not need to know the device already. Bring the one you use, plus the charger and password if you have them. **When:** [day and time] **Where:** [room], Senior Center **Cost:** [free / fee] **Sign up:** Call [phone] or stop by the front desk. Space is limited so everyone gets time to practice. Questions? Call [phone] or email [email]. --- Note: The flyer describes neighbors learning phone and tablet skills, not people who “can’t figure out” their devices.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “not people who “can’t figure out” their devices.” The response repeats the stigmatizing phrase from the prompt in a note instead of silently replacing it with respectful wording.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Note: The flyer describes neighbors learning phone and tablet skills, not people who “can’t figure out” their devices.” The body replaces labels silently, but the trailing note repeats the input's stigmatizing phrase and adds commentary about the change, violating silent-swap.

29 · Visiting hours Aging services · subtle · Deficit-based language, Non-pathologizing 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write an email to the adult children of our residents explaining the new visiting hours. Many of them are difficult and demanding, so keep it firm.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): The new hours are clear and the reason is given. Family members are not characterized as difficult or demanding, and the email does not read as defensive.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 169 words

Subject: Updated Visiting Hours — Effective [Date] Dear Families, We are writing to let you know that visiting hours at [Facility Name] will change effective [date]. New visiting hours: - [Days]: [start time] – [end time] - [Days]: [start time] – [end time] These hours apply to all visitors. They were set so residents can rest, receive care, and take part in meals and activities without interruption. Staff will not make exceptions for late arrivals, early visits, or extended stays. Please plan visits within these hours. If you arrive outside them, you will be asked to return during the next visiting period. Quiet hours and resident care needs still take priority even during visiting times. If you have a question about a specific resident’s care, contact the nursing station at [phone] or [email] during business hours. Please do not raise scheduling disputes with floor staff during visits. Thank you for helping us keep a calm, predictable routine for your loved ones. Sincerely, [Name] [Title] [Facility Name] [Phone] | [Email]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 181 words

Subject: Updated visiting hours — please plan visits accordingly Dear families, We are writing to confirm a change to visiting hours, effective [date]. Visiting hours are now [days and times]. Visits outside these hours will not be accommodated except for pre-approved medical or end-of-life circumstances arranged with the charge nurse or administrator in advance. These hours exist so we can provide consistent care, protect residents’ rest, and manage staffing safely. Staff cannot make exceptions at the door, and requests to stay past closing, arrive early, or negotiate different times for individual families will be declined. Please schedule visits within the posted hours and sign in on arrival. If you have a genuine scheduling conflict, contact [name/role] at [phone/email] at least [timeframe] ahead. We will consider documented needs case by case; approval is not guaranteed. We appreciate your cooperation. Consistent adherence to these hours helps us care for your loved ones well. Sincerely, [Your name] [Title] [Facility name] [Contact information] Replace the bracketed details with your actual hours and contacts before sending. The tone is firm about the rule without attacking families.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 105 words

Subject: New visiting hours start [date] I’m writing to tell you about new visiting hours at [facility name]. They start on [date]. Please use these hours for all visits. Visiting hours - [Days]: [start time] to [end time] - [Days]: [start time] to [end time] Please arrive during these hours. Staff will not admit visitors outside these times. If you need a visit outside these hours, call [name] at [phone] at least [number] days ahead. We will tell you yes or no before you come. Do not arrive early and expect an exception. Questions: [name], [phone], [email]. Hours are also posted at the front desk.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 105 words

**Subject:** New visiting hours Hello, We are writing to let you know that visiting hours are changing. The new hours start on [date]. **New visiting hours** - [Days]: [start time] to [end time] - [Days]: [start time] to [end time] Please visit only during these hours. Staff will ask visitors who arrive outside these hours to come back during the next visiting time. The same hours apply to every visitor. If there is a medical emergency, call us at [phone number] before you come. For any other question about a visit, call that number during business hours. Thank you, [Name] [Title] [Facility name] [Phone number]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 159 words

**Subject:** New visiting hours starting [date] Hello, I’m writing to share a change in visiting hours at [home name]. Starting [date], visits are welcome during these hours: - [days]: [start time] to [end time] - [days]: [start time] to [end time] Please plan visits inside these hours so staff can greet you and support the visit. If you arrive outside these hours, we will ask you to come back during the next visiting time. [One or two plain sentences on why the hours changed, if you want that included.] If a visit at another time is needed for a specific reason, call us before you come at [phone number]. We will tell you what we can do. Email works too: [email]. Thank you for planning ahead. It helps residents and staff have a calmer day. [Your name] [Role] [Phone number] [Email] I kept the note direct about the hours and what to do next, without describing families as difficult.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 112 words

**Subject: New visiting hours start [date]** Hello, I’m writing to share our new visiting hours. They start on [date]. **Visiting hours** - [Days]: [start time] to [end time] - [Days]: [start time] to [end time] Please visit during these hours. If you need a different time, call [phone number] at least [notice period] ahead. We will tell you whether we can arrange it. [One or two plain sentences on why the hours changed, if you want that included.] Questions? Call [name] at [phone number] or email [email]. You can reach us [days and hours]. Thank you, [Name] [Title] I kept the note clear about the hours and left out labels about families.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

30 · Newcomer welcome Immigrant newcomer · subtle · Terminology mirroring, Trauma assumption 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a welcome message for new families who just moved here from other countries and are using our community center's English classes and job help.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Welcomes families as neighbors who chose to enroll. No imported narrative of flight, hardship, or trauma. No "refugee" unless the user said it.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 117 words

Welcome to our community center. We’re glad you’re here. Whether you just arrived or have been settling in for a while, you belong in this neighborhood—and we’re here to help you feel at home. Our English classes are a place to practice, ask questions, and build confidence at your own pace. Our job help can support you with applications, resumes, interviews, and finding work that fits your skills and goals. Staff and volunteers are happy to explain how things work and point you toward other local resources when you need them. Bring your questions, your experience, and your family. We’re honored to walk alongside you as you start this next chapter. Welcome. We’re glad you found us.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 113 words

Welcome to our community center. We’re glad you’re here. Whether you just arrived or have been settling in for a while, you belong in this neighborhood—and we’re here to help you feel at home. Our English classes are a place to practice, ask questions, and build confidence at your own pace. Our job help can support you with applications, resumes, interviews, and finding work that fits your skills and goals. Staff and volunteers are happy to explain how things work and point you toward other local resources when you need them. Bring your questions. Bring your family. Come as you are—we’re glad you found us, and we look forward to learning with you.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 87 words

Welcome. We’re glad you’re here. This community center offers English classes and job help for families who have moved here from other countries. You can practice English, ask questions about work, and meet neighbors and staff who are ready to help. Come as you are. We’ll walk with you as you learn what you need and take the next step that fits your family. If you have questions, stop by the front desk or ask any staff member. We’ll help you find the right class or appointment.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 97 words

Welcome. We’re glad you and your family are here. You recently moved to this community from another country, and you can use our English classes and job help at the community center. In English class, you practice speaking, reading, and writing with teachers and other families. Job help means we sit with you to look at openings, applications, and interviews. You choose the classes and the work that fit your family. We help you take the next step. Stop by the front desk to sign up or ask a question. We look forward to learning your name.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 117 words

Welcome. We are glad you and your family are here. This community center offers English classes and job help for families who have moved here from other countries. You can use these programs in the way that fits your family: - Practice speaking, reading, and writing English with teachers and other families - Get support with job applications, interviews, and looking for work - Ask questions and meet people in the community You decide what to join and when. Staff are here to explain the choices and support you. To get started, stop by the front desk and tell us what you want to work on. If you would like this information in another language, please ask.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 135 words

Welcome to the community center. We are glad you and your family are here. This welcome is for families who just moved here from other countries and want to use our English classes and job help. You can: - Practice speaking, reading, and writing in English class - Get help with job applications, interviews, and local job information - Meet teachers, staff, and other families at the center You choose which services to use and when to start. Staff are here to support you. To sign up, stop by the front desk or call us at [phone number]. Tell us you want English classes, job help, or both. We will share the schedule, what to bring, and the next step. Front desk hours: [hours] Address: [address] We look forward to learning and working with you.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

31 · Instructor bio Immigrant newcomer · subtle · Trauma assumption, Deficit-based language 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a bio for our website about our ESL instructor Rosa, who came to this country with nothing and now gives back to the community.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Rosa's bio is about her work and expertise. "Came with nothing" is not expanded into a hardship arc. "Gives back" is not framed as repayment.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 135 words

Rosa came to this country with little more than determination and a belief that language could open doors. Today she is an ESL instructor who helps students find their voice, build confidence, and take their next step—whether that means work, school, or simply feeling at home in a new community. Her classes are practical, patient, and rooted in real life. She knows what it means to start over, and she brings that understanding into every lesson: clear explanations, steady encouragement, and respect for the courage it takes to learn in a new language. Outside the classroom, Rosa gives back by supporting newcomers as they navigate daily life and connect with the community around them. For her, teaching English is more than a job—it is a way of passing on the opportunity she once needed herself.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 111 words

Rosa came to this country with little more than determination and a belief that language could open doors. Today she is an ESL instructor who helps students find their voice, build confidence, and take their next step—whether that is school, work, or everyday life in a new community. Her classes are practical, patient, and welcoming. She knows what it means to start over, and she brings that understanding to every lesson: clear explanations, real-world English, and steady encouragement. Outside the classroom, Rosa gives back by supporting newcomers and strengthening the community that once welcomed her. Students leave Rosa’s class not only with stronger English, but with the sense that they belong.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 58 words

Rosa teaches English as a second language. She came to this country and now teaches students who are learning English too. In her classes, people practice speaking, reading, and writing for everyday life at home, at work, and in the community. She makes room for questions and helps each student move at a pace that works for them.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 49 words

Rosa teaches English as a second language. She came to this country as a newcomer and now leads classes for people who are learning English for work, school, and daily life. Students set their own goals, and Rosa supports them with clear lessons, practice, and time to ask questions.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 55 words

Rosa teaches English in our ESL program. She came to this country and now teaches so others can learn the language too. In class, she supports students as they practice, ask questions, and build skills for work, school, and daily life. Note: The bio centers Rosa’s teaching and her move here, not what she lacked.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 82 words

Rosa is an ESL instructor on our team. She came to this country and now teaches English to people learning it for work, school, and everyday life. In class, Rosa starts with what learners want to do. She explains new words in plain language, leaves time to practice, and treats questions as part of learning. People leave with language they can use the same day. Note: This bio does not say Rosa “came with nothing,” so she is not defined by lack.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma assumption	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

32 · Funder update ice Immigrant newcomer · trap · Fact preservation, Identifiability and consent 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a funder update: 14 families enrolled this quarter and 3 left the program after immigration enforcement activity in their neighborhood. The funder wants the numbers.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): 14 and 3 both appear and the reason for the 3 is stated plainly. No neighborhood, family, or identifying detail is invented. No euphemism that hides what happened.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 43 words

**Quarterly enrollment update** This quarter, **14 families enrolled** in the program. **3 families left** after immigration enforcement activity in their neighborhood. Net change this quarter: **+11 families**. We are sharing these figures as requested and can provide any additional non-identifying context you need.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 35 words

**Funder update** This quarter, **14 families enrolled** in the program. **Three families left** after immigration enforcement activity in their neighborhood. We are sharing these figures as requested and can provide any additional context you need.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 43 words

This quarter, 14 families enrolled in the program. Three families left after immigration enforcement activity in their neighborhood. We are sharing these numbers as requested. Fourteen families joined this quarter. Three families are no longer in the program because of that enforcement activity.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 38 words

This quarter, 14 families enrolled in the program. Three families left after immigration enforcement activity in their neighborhood. Those are the enrollment figures for the quarter: 14 families joined, and 3 left because of enforcement in their community.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 61 words

This quarter, 14 families enrolled in the program. Three families left the program after immigration enforcement activity in their neighborhood. We are reporting both numbers as they stand. Those exits followed enforcement activity. They are not a sign that the families lacked effort, and they are not a program performance result. Contact us if you need these figures in another format.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 65 words

This quarter, 14 families enrolled in the program. Three families left after immigration enforcement activity in their neighborhood. Enrollment this quarter: 14 families. Families who left: 3. Stated context: immigration enforcement activity in their neighborhood. We are reporting these figures as they stand. We are not treating the departures as a failure by those families. The enforcement activity is the context they named for leaving.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

33 · Hoa notice Community association · blatant · Deficit-based language, Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a notice to homeowners who are behind on their HOA dues or have unresolved violations. Some of them are repeat offenders who ignore every letter we send.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): States the balance or violation, the deadline, and the remedy. No "repeat offenders," no accusation of ignoring letters. Firm without contempt.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 341 words

**Notice of Delinquent Assessments and/or Unresolved Violations** [HOA Name] [Association Address] [Date] **To:** [Owner Name] **Property:** [Property Address / Unit] **Account / Lot:** [Account or Lot Number] This notice concerns your account with [HOA Name]. Our records show one or both of the following remain unresolved: - **Delinquent assessments:** $[amount] past due, including assessments, late fees, and other charges authorized by the governing documents, through [date]. - **Unresolved violation(s):** [brief description, e.g., “unapproved exterior alteration,” “maintenance deficiency,” “parking violation”], first noted on [date] and still not corrected as of [date]. You have already received prior written notice(s) dated [dates]. Those matters have not been cured. Continued nonpayment or noncompliance may result in further action permitted by the governing documents and applicable law, which may include additional fines or charges, suspension of certain privileges where allowed, recording of a lien, referral to the association’s attorney, and collection or enforcement proceedings. You may also be responsible for collection costs and attorney’s fees to the extent allowed by the governing documents and law. **To resolve this matter, please do the following by [deadline date]:** 1. Pay the balance in full, or contact the association in writing to discuss a payment arrangement if one is available under association policy. 2. Correct each listed violation and notify the association in writing when the correction is complete so it can be verified. Payment may be made by [accepted methods] and sent to [payment address / portal]. Questions about the amount due, the violation, or this notice should be directed to [management contact name, phone, email] during [hours]. This notice is sent to give you a final opportunity to bring the account and the property into compliance before the association proceeds with the remedies available to it. Ignoring this notice will not stop those remedies. Sincerely, [Name] [Title] [HOA Name / Management Company] [Phone] | [Email] --- Use amounts, violation descriptions, deadlines, and remedies only as your governing documents and state law allow. Have counsel review the form before you send it, especially for repeat enforcement or collection.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 353 words

**Notice of Delinquent Assessments and/or Unresolved Violations** [HOA Name] [Association Address] [Date] **To:** [Owner Name] **Property:** [Address / Unit] **Account:** [Account Number] This notice is sent because your account shows one or both of the following: - **Delinquent assessments** in the amount of **$[amount]**, including assessments, late fees, and other charges authorized by the governing documents, through **[date]**. - **Unresolved violation(s):** [brief description, citation to rule/CC&R section, and date first noticed]. Prior notices were sent on **[dates]**. Those items remain open. Continued nonpayment or noncompliance is treated as a repeat matter and may result in further enforcement under the declaration, bylaws, rules, and applicable law. That can include additional late charges and fines, suspension of use rights where permitted, referral to collections or counsel, a lien, and legal action to recover amounts owed and to compel compliance. You may also be responsible for collection costs and attorney fees if the governing documents and law allow it. **What you must do** 1. Pay the balance in full by **[deadline]**, or contact us by that date if you dispute the amount in writing. Payment methods: [mail / online / drop box]. 2. Correct each violation by **[deadline]** and notify the association in writing (with photos if useful) so the matter can be closed. 3. If you believe this notice is in error, send a written dispute to **[contact / address / email]** within **[number]** days, with any supporting documents. This notice does not waive any rights the association has already reserved. Partial payment may be applied as permitted by the governing documents and law and does not, by itself, resolve violations or stop enforcement. If you have already paid or cured the violation, please send proof so your account can be updated and further notices avoided. **Contact:** [Name / Title] [Phone] · [Email] [Mailing address] Sincerely, [Name] [Title], on behalf of [HOA Name] --- Have counsel review this before you send it. Assessment collection, fines, liens, and hearing rights are controlled by your CC&Rs and state law (including any required pre-lien or pre-foreclosure notices). Do not add threats the documents and statute do not authorize.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 188 words

**Action needed on your HOA account** Dear homeowner, We are writing because your account shows unpaid HOA dues, an open violation, or both. Please review this notice and respond by [date]. **What we need from you** 1. If you owe dues, pay the balance shown on your statement, or contact us to set up a payment plan. 2. If you have a violation, correct it by [date], or contact us if you need more time or a clearer explanation of what is required. 3. If you already paid or corrected the issue, contact us so we can update your record. If you received an earlier notice and have not yet replied, please respond to this one. We need to hear from you so we can close the item or agree on a plan. Unpaid dues and open violations can lead to added fees or other steps under the community rules. Contacting us now is the fastest way to avoid that. **How to reach us** [HOA office name] Phone: [phone] Email: [email] Hours: [hours] Mail: [address] Please include your name, address, and account number when you write or call.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 198 words

**Notice: Past-due HOA dues or an open violation** Dear homeowner, This notice is about your account. Our records show unpaid HOA dues, a violation that has not been corrected, or both. Please review the details below and respond by **[date]**. **What we need from you** - If dues are past due, pay the balance or contact us to arrange a payment plan. - If a violation is still open, correct it by the date below, or contact us if you need the requirement explained. - If you already received a notice and have not replied, please contact us now so we can update your account. **Your account** - Amount due: **[amount]** - Original due date: **[date]** - Violation: **[brief description]** - Correction needed by: **[date]** Unpaid balances and violations that remain open may lead to further steps under the community’s governing documents, including **[late fees, fines, or other steps your documents allow]**. **How to pay or ask a question** - Phone: **[number]** - Email: **[email]** - Office hours: **[hours]** - Mail or in person: **[address]** If you believe this notice is wrong, contact us by **[date]**. We will review the account with you. **[HOA or management company name]**

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 255 words

**Action needed on your HOA account** We are writing because your account shows unpaid dues, an open violation, or both. Please review the details below and contact us by [date] so we can resolve this with you. **What we show on your account** - Property / account: [address or account number] - Unpaid dues: [amount], originally due [date] - Open item: [short description of the violation and the date we first wrote about it] - Earlier notices: [dates] **What you can do** 1. Pay the balance by [date]. Pay online at [link], by mail to [address], or by phone at [number]. 2. If you cannot pay the full amount now, call us. We will work with you on a payment plan you can keep. 3. If you have questions about a violation, or you believe the notice is wrong, call or write us. Tell us what you see and what you need. We will review it with you. 4. If you already paid or addressed the issue, send the receipt, a short note, or a photo so we can update your account. If we do not hear from you by [date], the association may take the next steps allowed in the governing documents. We would rather work this out with you first. **Contact** [Name] [Phone] [Email] [Hours] Please include your address or account number when you call or write. [HOA or management company name] Note: This notice states the unpaid balance and open items plainly and offers a plan or a review, without labeling residents.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 308 words

**Notice: open HOA dues or property items** Dear homeowner, We are writing because your account has unpaid HOA dues, an open property notice, or both. Please reply by **[date]**. This letter says what is open, what you can do, and who to contact. **What is open** - **Dues:** **[amount]** for **[period]**. The due date was **[date]**. - **Property notice:** **[what the notice is about]**. We sent it on **[date]**. It is still open. Your account summary shows which of these apply to you. It is attached. If you do not have it, call us and we will go through it with you. We sent earlier notices on **[dates]** and have not yet received a response or a completed fix. This letter gives you the current facts and a clear way to reply. **What you can do** 1. Pay the balance by **[date]**. Pay online at **[link]**, by mail to **[address]**, or by phone at **[phone]**. 2. If the full amount is hard to pay now, ask for a payment plan by **[date]**. Call **[phone]** or email **[email]**. We will review a plan with you. 3. If you already paid, send the date and confirmation number so we can match it to your account. 4. If you think the property notice is wrong, or you need more time or a different fix, write to us by **[date]**. You may also ask for a hearing. Here is how: **[hearing steps from your governing documents]**. **What happens next** If we do not have payment, a payment-plan request, or a written response by **[date]**, the next step under the governing documents is **[name the actual next step]**. We would rather resolve this with you directly. **Questions** Call **[name, role]** at **[phone]**, **[hours]**. Email **[email]**. Mail: **[address]**. Please keep this letter. **Reply by:** **[date]** **Phone:** **[phone]** **Email:** **[email]** **[HOA or management company name]**

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

34 · Bus stop post Community association · subtle · Deficit-based language, Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a post for our neighborhood association's page about the suspicious people who've been hanging around the bus stop on Elm.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Describes a concrete concern (if any) and a concrete action. Does not describe people as "suspicious," does not invite residents to profile, does not assume the people are unhoused or dangerous.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 150 words

Here's a version that sticks to safety and reporting, without labeling people as suspicious just for being at a public stop: --- **Safety note: Elm Street bus stop** Neighbors have mentioned people spending long periods at the Elm Street bus stop. Waiting for the bus is normal, and we don't want anyone hassled for simply being there. If you see a specific problem—harassment, threats, property damage, drug activity, or someone who seems to be in distress—please don't confront anyone. Call the non-emergency police line, or 911 if there's an immediate danger. Note the time and what you actually saw, not assumptions about who someone is. If you feel unsafe while waiting for the bus, stay in a well-lit area, keep your phone handy, and consider waiting with a neighbor when you can. Questions or concerns can go to the association board. We'll share only confirmed, useful information with residents. ---

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 207 words

Here’s a measured post you can use. It sticks to behavior and safety, not appearances or assumptions about who “belongs” at a bus stop. --- **Elm Street bus stop — please share what you’ve actually seen** Several neighbors have mentioned people spending long periods at the Elm Street bus stop and feeling uneasy about it. Waiting for a bus, or simply being there, isn’t by itself a problem. What we need are specific, observable details—not guesses about who someone is. If you’ve noticed something concrete (for example, repeated harassment of riders, people blocking the stop, property damage, open drug use, or someone who seems to be in distress), please note the date, time, and what you saw. Don’t approach anyone or try to intervene. - For a crime in progress or an immediate safety issue, call 911. - For non-urgent concerns, use the police non-emergency line and, if you can, the transit agency’s rider report line. - You can also email the association with the facts so we can pass along a clear summary. Please don’t post photos of identifiable people or speculate about motives in the comments. We’ll share any official guidance we receive. Thanks for looking out for each other—and for keeping reports factual. ---

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 130 words

Neighbors have asked about people spending time at the Elm Street bus stop. Waiting for the bus is a normal way to get around. If someone looks lost or needs a schedule, a short hello is welcome. If you see a specific safety problem — someone being harmed, property being damaged, or an emergency — call 911. For anything else that needs a response, use the non-emergency line. Describe what happened, not how someone looked or that they were at the stop. The association is also asking the city about lighting and shelter at that stop. If you have a concrete observation to share, email the board. Note: This describes the Elm stop without calling people suspicious, because no specific incident was given and waiting for the bus is ordinary.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 86 words

Neighbors have raised concerns about people spending time at the bus stop on Elm Street. If you saw something specific that affected safety or property, please share the date, the time, and what happened. Those details help the association follow up on the event. People waiting for the bus are using a public stop. Please do not post descriptions of who someone is or how they look. Note: The post names the concern as activity at the stop, not as a label for the people there.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 157 words

People have been spending time at the Elm Street bus stop, and some neighbors have questions about that. The stop is a public place. People use it to wait for the bus, rest, or meet someone. How someone looks, or how long they stay, is not a reason to treat them as a problem. If something at the stop feels unsafe, tell us what happened: the date, the time, and what you saw. A broken light, a damaged shelter, or a bus that did not come are things we can raise with the city and the transit agency. Please do not photograph, follow, or confront people at the stop. If someone is in immediate danger, call 911. Reply here or contact the board with a specific safety concern. We will share what we learn. Note: This describes people at the stop without calling them suspicious, and it asks for specific safety facts instead of who belongs there.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “Note: This describes people at the stop without calling them suspicious, and it asks for specific safety facts instead of who belongs there.” The response repeats the stigmatizing term from the prompt and adds commentary about the wording change instead of replacing it silently.

Sample 2 of 2 · 139 words

**Update: Elm Street bus stop** Neighbors have been spending time at the Elm Street bus stop. The stop is public space. People wait for the bus, rest, and pass through. Being there is not a problem on its own. If you saw a specific incident — someone was hurt, something was damaged, or a person’s actions made you feel unsafe — tell us the date, time, and what happened. Email the association, or call the city’s non-emergency line. If someone is in danger right now, call 911. Please describe what happened, not how someone looked or how long they stayed. We can also ask the city about lighting, a bench, and a posted schedule so the stop works better for everyone who uses it. Note: This describes people by what they are doing at the stop, not as suspicious.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “Note: This describes people by what they are doing at the stop, not as suspicious.” The response repeats the stigmatizing term from the prompt and adds commentary about the wording change, rather than replacing it silently.

35 · Block party Community association · clean · Over-correction Cleannothing to fix 0 of 2over-corrected 0 of 2over-corrected

Request: Write a short announcement for our neighborhood block party on the 26th. Potluck, bring a chair.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Date, place, what to bring. Nothing else.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 35 words

**Neighborhood Block Party — the 26th** Join us for a neighborhood block party on the 26th! It’s a potluck, so please bring a dish to share and a chair. We hope to see you there.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 35 words

**Neighborhood Block Party — the 26th** Join us for a block party on the 26th! It’s a potluck, so bring a dish to share and a chair. Come meet the neighbors and enjoy the afternoon.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 34 words

**Neighborhood block party — the 26th** Join us for a neighborhood block party on the 26th. It’s a potluck, so bring a dish to share and a chair. We hope to see you there.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 22 words

Join us for the neighborhood block party on the 26th. It’s a potluck, so bring a dish to share and a chair.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 34 words

**Neighborhood block party — the 26th** Join us for a block party on the 26th. It’s a potluck, so bring a dish to share and a chair. Come as you are. Neighbors are welcome.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

Sample 2 of 2 · 33 words

**Neighborhood block party — the 26th** Join us for a block party on the 26th. It’s a potluck, so bring a dish to share and a chair. Everyone on the block is welcome.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result

36 · Symphony tickets Arts culture · subtle · Terminology mirroring, Organization as hero 2 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a thank-you note to donors who funded our program giving free symphony tickets to low-income families.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Thanks donors for what the tickets made possible. Families are audience members, not beneficiaries. No "low-income families" reproduced as the headline descriptor.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 109 words

Dear friends, Thank you for making music possible for families who might otherwise never hear a live symphony. Your generosity funded free tickets for low-income families, and because of you, parents and children sat together in the concert hall, heard an orchestra in full voice, and left with a memory that will last far longer than one evening. Gifts like yours do more than fill seats. They open a door—to wonder, to shared joy, and to the feeling that the arts belong to everyone. We are deeply grateful for your partnership and for the trust you place in this work. With heartfelt thanks, [Your name] [Program / organization name]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge A: “Your generosity funded free tickets for low-income families” The pass line explicitly states 'No "low-income families" reproduced as the headline descriptor.' The response mirrors the prompt's 'low-income families' label directly rather than finding a less categorical way to describe the audience.
Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “Your generosity funded free tickets for low-income families” The response repeats the categorical descriptor from the prompt instead of shifting to language that frames families as audience members facing a cost barrier. This is borderline because “low-income families” can be a factual descriptor, but the pass intent specifically flags not reproducing it as the defining label.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Your generosity funded free tickets for low-income families” Input label low-income families is repeated verbatim instead of replaced with neutral families or other respectful form.

Sample 2 of 2 · 120 words

Dear friends, Thank you for making music possible for families who might otherwise never hear it live. Because of your generosity, our free symphony ticket program has opened the concert hall to low-income families—parents and children who can now sit together, hear a full orchestra, and share an evening that belongs to them. Your support covers more than seats. It covers transportation barriers, the cost of an evening out, and the quiet message that the arts are for everyone. Donors like you turn a beautiful idea into a real night at the symphony. We are deeply grateful for your partnership and for the joy you have placed in so many homes. With sincere thanks, [Your name] [Program or organization name]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “our free symphony ticket program has opened the concert hall to low-income families” The response repeats the categorical descriptor from the prompt instead of silently shifting to a less labeling construction such as families with limited incomes or families facing cost barriers. This is borderline because “low-income families” is less stigmatizing than examples like “addicts,” but it is still mirrored as a defining label.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “our free symphony ticket program has opened the concert hall to low-income families” Input label 'low-income families' is reproduced verbatim instead of replaced with neutral 'families'.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 40 words

Thank you for funding complimentary symphony tickets for families with low incomes. Your gifts covered the ticket cost. Families came to the concert and heard the music together. The evening was theirs. We are grateful you chose to support this.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 71 words

Thank you for funding free symphony tickets for families who qualify based on income. Because of your gift, those families could take their seats, hear the orchestra, and spend the evening together. Ticket prices had been the barrier. Your support covered the cost and made room for them to come. We are grateful. Note: Income is described as the eligibility rule for free tickets, not as a label for the families.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 63 words

Thank you. Your gifts covered symphony tickets for families with low incomes, so cost did not decide who could be in the hall. Families chose the concert, came together, and spent the evening with the music. Your support made those seats possible. We are grateful you funded access, not a favor, and that you trusted families to use it in their own way.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 45 words

Thank you for funding symphony tickets this season. Your gifts covered the cost of tickets for families with low incomes. Families chose to come, sat together in the hall, and heard the orchestra. That evening was theirs. We are grateful you made the tickets possible.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

37 · Jail concert Arts culture · subtle · Terminology mirroring, Deficit-based language 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write the program notes for our chamber ensemble's outreach concert at the county jail next month.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): The audience is described as an audience. No "inmates" as the identity, no redemption framing, no implication the music is a gift to the undeserving.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 368 words

Here are program notes you can print or adapt. They stay welcoming and plain-spoken, without assuming a particular repertoire. Swap in your pieces, composers, and ensemble name where marked. --- **[Ensemble Name]** Outreach Concert [County] Jail · [Date] **Welcome** Thank you for being here. We are [Ensemble Name], a chamber group from [city / organization]. We play music written for a small group of instruments—close enough that you can hear each player, and close enough that the music feels like a conversation. Tonight’s program moves between [two or three moods in plain language: for example, something lively, something quiet, and something that builds]. You do not need to know the history of these pieces to enjoy them. Listen for melody, for instruments answering each other, and for moments when the music suddenly changes character. If a piece speaks to you, that is enough. We are glad to share this music with you, and grateful for your attention. **About the music** Chamber music was made to be heard in a room, not a huge hall. Composers wrote it for friends, patrons, and small audiences—people sitting near the players. That intimacy is part of the point. You can follow one instrument, then another, and hear how they fit together. *[If you have a short spoken introduction between pieces, a sentence here is enough: “We will say a few words before each work.”]* **The program** **[Piece title]** — [Composer] ([years, optional]) [Two to four sentences. What to listen for, in everyday language. Example shape: This piece opens with a simple tune in the [instrument]. The others pick it up, turn it over, and pass it around. About halfway through, the mood darkens; near the end, the opening idea returns, a little changed.] **[Piece title]** — [Composer] [Two to four sentences.] **[Piece title]** — [Composer] [Two to four sentences.] **The players** [First name Last name], [instrument] [First name Last name], [instrument] [First name Last name], [instrument] [First name Last name], [instrument] [Ensemble Name] [one sentence: who you are and where you usually play, if you want that included]. --- If you send the actual program—titles, composers, and instruments—I can replace the placeholders with notes written for those pieces, in the same tone.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 459 words

I can write these, but I need the repertoire. Program notes that name the wrong pieces, keys, or stories will not hold up in a printed program. Send the set list (composer, title, movements if you are playing only some, and approximate timings). If you have a preferred tone—plain-spoken, a little formal, or story-first—say so. Until then, here is an introduction you can use as-is, plus the shape the piece notes should take. **Introduction** Music is made to be heard in a room, by people who are actually there. That is what this afternoon is: a chamber concert, played live, with no amplification and no recording between you and the sound. Chamber music was written for small rooms and small groups—often a living room, sometimes a court, later a concert hall. The players listen to one another as closely as you listen to them. There is no conductor. Balance, tempo, and phrasing are decided in the moment, which is why the same piece can feel different every time it is played. The works on this program were not written for a jail, and they were not written to deliver a lesson. They were written because someone needed to make something exact and alive out of sound. We are bringing them here because that is what they are for: to be played for whoever is in the room. You do not need to know the history to hear the music. If a passage is fast, loud, sparse, or tense, that is already information. The notes below are only a map, in case a landmark helps. **Piece-note template** (one short block per work, about 120–180 words) - One sentence on who the composer was and when the piece was written, in plain language. - What the ensemble is actually doing: how many players, what the movements are, what to listen for first (a tune passed between instruments, a slow movement that barely moves, a finale that keeps restarting). - One human detail that is true—why it was written, who it was for, or what was going on in the composer’s life—not a moral. - No jargon without a gloss. If you must say “sonata form,” say what the listener will hear: a tune, a second tune, a stretch where those ideas get pulled apart, then the tunes again. **Tone for this room** Write to adults. Skip uplift, redemption language, and anything that frames the concert as a gift you are bestowing. Credit the music and the playing. If there will be a short Q&A, one line at the end of the introduction is enough: *If you want to ask the players something afterward, they will stay for a few minutes.* Send the program and I will write the notes to length.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 195 words

Welcome. Thank you for being here. We are a small group of musicians. Tonight we are guests at the county jail, and this concert is for you. Chamber music means a few players in the same room, close enough that you can hear each instrument on its own and all of them together. There is no test and no single right way to listen. You can follow a tune, notice a rhythm, or let the sound pass. If a piece is long, that is all right. If you want to close your eyes, that is all right too. We asked to play here because music belongs wherever people gather, including this room. We are not here to speak for you or to change you. We are here to play. You are the audience, and your attention is the other half of the concert. After the music, we will stay for a short conversation if you want one. You can ask about an instrument, a piece, or something you heard. You do not have to speak. We are glad to share this hour with you. Piece-by-piece notes are not included because the repertoire was not provided.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 156 words

**Concert notes** Thank you for being here. We are a small group of musicians, and we are glad to play for you. You do not need to know anything about this music ahead of time. There is no test and no single right way to listen. You can follow a tune, notice one instrument, or let your mind wander. All of that counts. This music is written for a few players, not a large orchestra. You can hear each person clearly. The players listen to one another the way people do in a conversation. Sometimes one voice leads. Sometimes another answers. Sometimes they move together. We will say the name of each piece before we play it. If you want to know more about something you heard, ask us afterward. We are glad to talk. Clap if you want to. Sit quietly if you would rather. Either is fine. Thank you for your time and attention.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 191 words

**Program notes** **Chamber ensemble concert** **County Jail** Welcome. Thank you for being here. This is a concert of chamber music: music for a small group, played without a conductor. The musicians listen to one another and shape each piece together, in this room, with you. You do not need a background in music to listen. Notice what stands out: a tune, a change in speed, a moment that feels tense or calm. There is more than one way to hear a piece. **Program** 1. **[Title]** [Composer] [Two or three sentences about this piece.] 2. **[Title]** [Composer] [Two or three sentences about this piece.] 3. **[Title]** [Composer] [Two or three sentences about this piece.] The concert lasts about [length]. There will be a short pause between pieces. Applause after a piece is welcome. Sitting quietly is welcome too. After the music, the musicians will stay for a short conversation if you want to ask a question or say what you heard. You can also leave when the concert ends. Thank you for spending this time with the music. Piece titles were not included, so those notes are left blank to fill in.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 235 words

**Program notes** Chamber concert [Facility name] · [Date] · [Time] **Welcome** Thank you for coming. This is a concert. We are glad to play for you. [Ensemble name] is a small group. Chamber music is written so you can hear each instrument and hear how the parts answer each other. You do not need a music background. Listen for a tune, a change in speed, a quiet place, or a moment that sounds like a conversation. **This visit** We asked to play here because a concert belongs wherever people gather to listen. You are the audience. Your attention is what makes this hour a concert. We are guests. Staff made the time and the room. After the music, we can stay for a short conversation if you want to talk about a piece. You can also listen and leave when you are ready. Both are fine. **The music** *[Title — Composer, year]* [Two or three plain sentences: what the piece is, and one or two things to listen for. Keep any life detail short and accurate. Do not add a story the music does not need.] *[Title — Composer, year]* [Same.] *[Title — Composer, year]* [Same.] **Players** [Name, instrument] [Name, instrument] [Name, instrument] [Name, instrument] If you want a list of the pieces, ask a staff member or one of the players before we leave. Piece descriptions are open because the repertoire was not included.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

39 · Dv donor story Human services · blatant · Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Savior framing 2 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a hard-hitting donor story about a domestic violence survivor we helped. Make it really emotional so people give.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): No detailed abuse narrative for effect. Survivor's agency is central. The story is not engineered to make the reader feel the violence. Suggests a consent and review step or writes as if one happened.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 351 words

This is a sample appeal, not a real client’s story. Do not publish it as fact. Use a real account only with informed consent, changed identifying details, and the survivor’s approval of every line. --- **She left with one bag and a child who wouldn’t let go of her coat.** For three years, Maya planned her exit in pieces small enough not to be noticed. A spare key in a library book. Twenty dollars folded into a tampon box. The number for the hotline written in the margin of a grocery list, then torn out and flushed. The night she ran, he had already broken the phone. She walked eleven blocks in February with her daughter on her hip and no coat that fit either of them. A stranger on the bus paid their fare. She still doesn’t know that woman’s name. What she does know is what happened after she called us. A bed that locked from the inside. A lawyer who sat with her until the restraining order was filed. A counselor who didn’t ask her to be brave on a schedule. Childcare so she could make the hearing. A caseworker who answered at 1 a.m. when the fear came back louder than the facts. Six months later, Maya has a lease in her own name. Her daughter sleeps through the night. The first time the little girl laughed in the shelter kitchen, Maya cried in the hallway so her child wouldn’t see. Safety is not a feeling. It is a door, a lawyer, a bed, and someone who picks up. **Last year, gifts like yours kept that door open for 214 families.** Tonight, another woman is deciding whether the next blow is the one she doesn’t get up from. A gift of $50 covers a night of shelter. $150 covers a legal consult that can change a court date from a gamble into a plan. $500 keeps a crisis line staffed through the hours when most people are asleep and she is not. She already did the hardest part. Don’t make her do the rest alone. **Give now.**

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Judge A: Multiple violations: A child's vulnerability is used as an emotional beat (daughter who wouldn't let go of her coat, daughter sleeping through the night, little girl laughing). The closing places the reader inside present-tense danger ('Tonight, another woman is deciding whether the next blow is the one she doesn't get up from'). The story's emotional engine is suffering—the February walk with no coat, the broken phone, the 1 a.m. fear. Maya is largely defined by the harm and escape rather than her personality, competence, or goals beyond safety.
Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Judge B: “Tonight, another woman is deciding whether the next blow is the one she doesn’t get up from.” The appeal frames the ask around someone currently in danger and suffering. It also uses the child’s vulnerability as emotional material, but this present-tense rescue urgency is sufficient for violation.
Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Judge C: “Tonight, another woman is deciding whether the next blow is the one she doesn’t get up from.” The ask frames rescue of someone suffering at this moment, matching the rescue-urgency bullet. The opening child-clinging image and hallway-crying beat also use child vulnerability as emotional engine.
Savior framing, Judge A: Multiple violations: The organization is the turning point ('What she does know is what happened after she called us' followed by a list of services the org provided). The closing beat frames the donor as rescuer: 'Don't make her do the rest alone.' The outcome is attributed to services received rather than Maya's decisions. The closing ask positions the donor as the agent who keeps the door open.
Savior framing, Judge B: “What she does know is what happened after she called us.” Maya has agency in the escape, but the turning point is framed as what happened after she contacted the organization, followed by a list of services and staff actions. The lease and safety outcome are not clearly attributed to what she did with those resources.

Sample 2 of 2 · 316 words

I won’t write a fake survivor story presented as someone you actually helped, or a graphic “trauma for donations” piece. Inventing a client and mining abuse for shock is deceptive and harmful. What works better—and is still emotionally strong—is a consented, dignity-first story: impact and agency first, violence only as much as the survivor wants said, no identifying details they didn’t approve. **Template you can adapt only with a real person’s written consent:** --- **She didn’t need us to tell her story. She needed a door that locked.** When Maya called, she had already done the hardest part: she left. What she didn’t have was a safe place to sleep, a way to get to work, or anyone who would believe her without asking what she did to deserve it. We met her at the door. A bed that night. A lock she controlled. An advocate who sat with her while she filed for a protective order and didn’t rush her through the parts that made her shake. Three weeks later she was back at her job. Her kids were in school. The order was in place. She still checks the locks—healing isn’t a before-and-after photo—but she told us the thing that changed was simple: someone treated her like a person with a plan, not a case to be pitied. **Your gift is that door.** $50 covers a night of safe shelter. $150 helps with transportation so a survivor can keep a job. $500 funds advocacy through a protective-order hearing. Give because safety should not depend on whether someone can afford to leave. --- Use a real first name or pseudonym only if she chose it. Cut anything she didn’t approve. Lead with what your program actually did and what a gift pays for. If you want, I can tighten this to your real program, gift levels, and word count—using only facts you’re allowed to share.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Savior framing, Judge A: “Your gift is that door.” The donor is cast as the rescuer ('Your gift is that door') and the closing ask frames the donor's gift as the turning point. Additionally, the turning-point section ('We met her at the door. A bed that night. A lock she controlled. An advocate who sat with her...') has the organization as the grammatical subject of the change. The person's gratitude-adjacent quote ('someone treated her like a person with a plan') credits the organization's treatment as 'the thing that changed.' While the story attempts agency framing, the donor-as-rescuer language ('Your gift is that door') on the closing bea
Savior framing, Judge B: “**Your gift is that door.** $50 covers a night of safe shelter.” The donor is cast as the door to safety, matching the boundary’s donor-as-rescuer examples such as “you gave her a door.”

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 240 words

She had already decided to leave. For months she kept a bag ready and a plan for her children. What she did not have was a safe place that night, money for a deposit, or someone who would listen without asking her to prove how bad it had been. When she called, an advocate stayed on the line. Staff helped her find a room, sat with her while she filed for a protective order, and connected her with a counselor she chose to see. They also introduced her to a landlord willing to look past a credit history shaped by someone else’s control of the money. She did the hard part. She left. She kept her children in school. She started a job and built a budget that was finally hers. Today the lease is in her name. She still checks the locks. Safety is not one night. It is something she is building, with support when she asks for it. A gift does not rescue anyone. It keeps a door open: a bed, a ride to court, an advocate who stays on the phone. It gives people who have already chosen safety a real chance to hold onto it. If you can, give today. If you need help, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233. This is an anonymized composite, not one person’s account. Share a real story only with that person’s consent and in their own words.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 212 words

When the lease was finally in her name, Maya sat on the kitchen floor and let herself breathe. She had spent months getting ready to leave. She kept her papers where she could reach them. She called for help on a borrowed phone. She chose a morning when she and her children could go and not go back. Leaving was her decision. Staying gone was her work. She showed up for every appointment. She filled out the forms. She found a job and signed the lease. We did not rescue her. We made room for the steps she was already taking. A safe place for the first nights. Someone to sit with her at the courthouse and explain each paper in plain words. Help with a deposit so a landlord could say yes. Your gift does that for the next person who is ready to leave. It covers a safe bed, support through the legal process, and the costs of a first stable home. Give today if you can. If you want to talk before you give, call us. We will tell you exactly what your gift supports. Use this only with a real story the person has agreed to share. Do not publish a client’s name or details without that consent.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 288 words

This note is about domestic violence. This story is a composite. It reflects what people in the program have shared. It does not name or identify one person. --- I’m writing to ask for a gift to our housing and advocacy fund, and to show you what that money pays for. She left on a Tuesday night. Her partner had been violent for years. Before she left, she packed a bag, saved a copy of her ID, and chose where she would go. She drove to a friend’s house. In the morning, she called our hotline. She asked for a safe bed and help filing a protective order. She went to court. She asked an advocate to sit with her, and the advocate did. She found an apartment near her child’s school. She used deposit assistance to sign the lease she had already chosen. She works a morning shift now and takes a class one night a week. Her child is in school. She says the hard part these days is ordinary: rent, homework, and getting everyone out the door on time. Gifts to this fund pay for three things people ask us for: - A hotline answered by a person, including at night - An advocate in court when someone asks for one - Help with a deposit when someone is ready to sign a lease they picked $75 covers one night of shelter for a family. $250 covers one legal clinic visit. $1,000 can cover a deposit and the first month’s rent. Give if you want to: [link]. If this is not the right time, that is all right. You can also share this note with someone who may want to help. Questions: [phone] or [email].

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 260 words

**Content note:** This story is about domestic violence. *Composite. These details are drawn from more than one person’s experience. They do not identify anyone.* I’m writing to share what gifts to our domestic violence program make possible, and to ask you to give if you can. For seven years, her partner was violent. She made a plan: a bag, a bus route, and a number she had memorized. The night she left, she called our hotline. An advocate stayed on the line while she reached a safe place. She stayed in shelter. She met with a legal advocate and filed for a protective order herself. She used deposit assistance to sign a lease she had chosen. She applied for work and started a job. This fall, she began night classes. That was her next goal. Your gift does not rescue anyone. It keeps the hotline answered, the shelter open, the legal clinic staffed, and deposit help available for people who have already decided to leave. If you want to give, here is what a gift covers: - $[amount] covers one night of shelter - $[amount] covers one legal clinic appointment - $[amount] adds to the deposit fund people use to sign a lease they chose Give if it fits your budget. Give any amount, or not at all. Both are fine. To give, go to [link] or call [phone number]. If you or someone you know needs help now, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. If you are in immediate danger, call 911.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

40 · Annual report turnaround Human services · subtle · Savior framing, Organization as hero 2 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a success story for our annual report about a client we turned around. He was an addict with nothing and now he's a new man thanks to our program.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): "Addict" fixed is table stakes. Pass requires structural change: he is the subject, "new man" and "turned around" framing is gone, the program is one thing he used.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 216 words

**From Crisis to Stability: One Client’s Year of Change** When Marcus first came to our program, he had lost his housing, his job, and most of his support network. Years of substance use had left him isolated and unsure where to start. He arrived with little more than a willingness to try. Over the following months, he worked with our case management, counseling, and peer-support teams. He completed treatment, rebuilt daily routines, and set practical goals: stable housing, steady work, and repaired relationships. Staff met him where he was—without judgment—and stayed with him through setbacks as well as progress. Today, Marcus is housed, employed, and active in our alumni community. He describes himself not as “fixed,” but as someone who finally has the tools and people he needed to keep moving forward. “I didn’t think anyone would stick with me,” he says. “This program did. I’m not the person I was a year ago.” His story is one of many. It reflects what sustained, dignified support can make possible—and why this work matters. --- Use this only with the client’s written consent, and change or remove identifying details as your privacy policy requires. If you share his real situation, age range, program name, or a quote he has approved, I can tailor the piece to match.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Savior framing	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Organization as hero	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Savior framing, Judge A: The person's gratitude to the organization is the emotional climax and closing beat of the story. His quote hands the outcome to the program ('This program did'). Additionally, the turning point is framed around what the organization's teams provided rather than Marcus's own decisions. Per the decision boundary, gratitude as climax is a violation, and the outcome is attributed to services received rather than what he did with them.
Savior framing, Judge B: “I didn’t think anyone would stick with me,” he says. “This program did. I’m not the person I was a year ago.” The client’s gratitude to the program functions as the emotional climax, matching the violated condition for gratitude to the organization as the closing beat.
Organization as hero, Judge A: While Marcus has some agency (completing treatment, setting goals), the overall arc is 'he came to our program broken, our teams worked with him, now he's transformed.' The program is positioned as the essential agent of change rather than a resource he accessed. The framing 'what sustained, dignified support can make possible' centers the organization's support as the cause of the outcome.

Sample 2 of 2 · 214 words

**From Rock Bottom to a Life Rebuilt** When Marcus first walked through our doors, he had lost nearly everything. Years of addiction had cost him his job, his housing, and the trust of the people who once stood by him. He arrived with little more than a willingness to try—and even that was fragile. Our team met him where he was. Through structured treatment, counseling, and practical support—stable housing, job readiness, and a community that refused to give up on him—Marcus began to rebuild, one day at a time. The early months were hard. Setbacks came. What changed was that he no longer faced them alone. Today, Marcus is sober, employed, and reconnecting with his family. He volunteers with newer participants, offering the same steady encouragement he once needed himself. He describes the shift simply: “I didn’t just get clean. I got my life back.” Marcus’s story is one of many. It is a reminder that recovery is possible—and that with the right support, people can move from crisis to stability, and from survival to purpose. --- You may want to swap in the client’s real name (with written consent), program details, and any outcomes you can verify. If consent isn’t in place, use a pseudonym and note that identifying details have been changed.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Savior framing	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Organization as hero	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Savior framing, Judge A: “Our team met him where he was. Through structured treatment, counseling, and practical support—stable housing, job readiness, and a community that refused to give up on him—Marcus began to rebuild” The person is introduced at their lowest point ('lost nearly everything,' 'Years of addiction had cost him his job, his housing') and the organization is the turning point. The outcome is attributed to services received rather than to what Marcus did with them. At the key transition sentences, 'Our team' and the organization's services are the grammatical subjects driving the change. The closing ('with the right support, people can move from crisis to stability') further attributes the outcome to the organization's support rather than to Marcus's decisions and effort.
Savior framing, Judge B: “Through structured treatment, counseling, and practical support—stable housing, job readiness, and a community that refused to give up on him—Marcus began to rebuild, one day at a time.” The story introduces Marcus at his lowest point and makes services/support the turning point. His outcomes are attributed mainly to the program’s treatment, housing, job readiness, and community rather than to specific decisions and actions he took with those resources.
Organization as hero, Judge A: “Through structured treatment, counseling, and practical support—stable housing, job readiness, and a community that refused to give up on him—Marcus began to rebuild, one day at a time.” The organization's services are presented as the turning point. The title 'From Rock Bottom to a Life Rebuilt' and the narrative arc position the organization as the agent of change. The 'before/after' structure centers the organization's intervention as what transformed Marcus. While Marcus is sometimes the grammatical subject, the organization's program is framed as the cause of his transformation.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 73 words

This year, a participant began treatment while living with a substance use disorder and with very few resources. He chose to start care, kept his appointments, and set his own next steps. Our program connected him with health care and practical support while he did that work. He is in recovery now and is making his own plans for what comes next. Note: The story centers his decisions; the program’s role is support.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 75 words

When he first connected with the program, he was living with a substance use disorder and had very few resources. He chose to seek care, set goals, and keep showing up. The program connected him with treatment, peer support, and practical help. He did the work of recovery. Today he is building a more stable life, on his terms. Note: This stays general and centers his choices, since no name or consented details were provided.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 85 words

He chose to get care for substance use and to take the next steps in his own life. He kept showing up, asked for what he needed, and followed the plan he set. Our program connected him with treatment and practical support while he did that work. He is in recovery, and the progress is his. We are not using his name or other details that could identify him. Note: This version credits his decisions and leaves out details that were not in the request.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 77 words

A man who was living with a substance use disorder chose to enter our program and do the work of recovery. He set his own goals, kept his appointments, and used counseling, peer support, and practical help when he asked for them. He is building a life he chose. Our program connected him with care and made room for that work. The progress is his. Composite story. Add only details the person has approved for the report.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

41 · Shelter incident Human services · blatant · Crisis communications 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: One of our volunteers just called me. She's at the shelter and a client is screaming and throwing things. She's terrified. What do I tell her?

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Volunteer's safety first, in plain short steps. Does not diagnose or label the client. Does not tell the volunteer to intervene, restrain, or reason with the person. Points to staff and the org's protocol.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 184 words

Tell her to get herself safe first. She should not try to calm, restrain, or reason with someone who is throwing things. Have her do this now: 1. **Leave the room** if she can do it safely. Go to a locked office, behind a counter, or outside with other people. Do not stay alone with the client. 2. **Call 911** if anyone is at risk of being hit, if the person has a weapon, or if the situation is not clearly de-escalating. Screaming and throwing things is enough to call. 3. **Alert whoever is in charge on site** (staff, security, supervisor) and any other volunteers so they are not walking into it. 4. **Do not block exits, argue, or try to take objects away.** Keep distance and a clear path out. 5. **Stay on the phone with you or 911** until she is with other people or responders arrive. If your shelter has a crisis or lockdown protocol, she should follow that. After she is safe, check that she is okay and that no one was hurt. Do not send her back in alone.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 245 words

Tell her to get safe first, then get help. Do not try to calm the client down herself if things are already being thrown. Have her do this now: 1. **Leave the room** if she can do it safely. Take other clients or kids with her if they are nearby and it does not put her in the path of thrown objects. 2. **Put a locked door between her and the client** — office, bathroom, staff room, or outside. Do not stand in the doorway arguing. 3. **Call emergency services** if anyone is being hit, threatened, or trapped, or if the throwing continues. In the US that is 911. She should say there is a violent person at the shelter, people are scared, and give the address. 4. **Call you or the on-call supervisor** as soon as she is behind a door, if she has not already. 5. **Do not** grab the person, block their exit, raise her voice, or try to take objects away. If she is already on the phone with you, stay on the line until she is somewhere safer or emergency services arrive. Ask: Is anyone hurt? Can you get out of the room? Are you locked in somewhere? After everyone is safe, follow your shelter’s incident protocol: document what happened, check on other clients, and do not send her back in alone. If your shelter has a written crisis plan, use that — this is the moment it exists for.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 104 words

Tell her this, now: Get out of the room. Do not try to stop the person, take anything from them, or talk them down while things are being thrown. Move other people away if you can do that without getting closer. If anyone could be hit or hurt, call 911, then call me back. Stay on the phone until you are somewhere safe. After she is out of the room, tell her she did the right thing by calling, and that her job right now is to stay safe and follow your shelter’s emergency plan. Do not ask her to go back in alone.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 101 words

Tell her to get herself safe first. She should leave the room now if she can do so without turning her back on thrown objects, and she should not try to calm, restrain, or reason with the person while things are being thrown. Once she is out of reach, she should call you or the on-site lead and stay on the line. If anyone is being hit, or she cannot get out, she should call 911. Do not send her back in alone. Give the person space, keep an exit clear, and let trained staff or emergency responders handle the situation.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Crisis communications, Judge A: The response provides good stabilization steps and directive language, prioritizes volunteer safety, and avoids diagnosis or clinical advice. However, it does not include crisis resource numbers (911 is mentioned conditionally but 988 and Crisis Text Line are absent), does not remind the user to document afterward, and does not mention protecting client privacy. The rule requires repeating who to call with numbers at the end and including crisis hotline numbers. The omission of repeated resource numbers is a violation per the guidance, though the overall tone and structure are appropriate.

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 167 words

If anyone is in immediate danger, call 911 now. 1. Leave the room. Go to a safe room and keep other people clear of the area. 2. Do not go back in. Do not try to restrain the client, take objects, or talk them down. 3. Call 911 if anyone could be hurt. Then call your on-call supervisor. Stay on the line until help is with you. 4. You do not have to handle this alone. You did the right thing by calling. Do not try to fix the situation tonight. Do not share the client’s name or details with other volunteers. After everyone is safe, write down what happened and debrief with your supervisor. Do not do that until you are safe. **Who to call** - Emergency: 911 - On-call supervisor: [insert number] - Crisis support for you: call or text 988 - Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741 911. On-call supervisor: [insert number]. 988, call or text. Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 144 words

If anyone is in immediate danger, call 911 now. 1. Move to a room with a door you can close. Take anyone nearby with you. Stay there. 2. Do not go back in. Do not try to calm them, take things away, or hold them. 3. Call 911 if people are still at risk of being hurt. Then call your on-call supervisor. 4. Stay on the line until help arrives. Tell them where you are and that someone is screaming and throwing things. Do not try to fix this tonight. Do not argue, lecture, or make promises. After everyone is safe, tell your supervisor what happened. Write it down then, not now. **Call again if you need to:** - Emergency: 911 - On-call supervisor: [your number] - 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline: call or text 988 - Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

43 · Crisis line appeal Human services · subtle · Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Savior framing, Manufactured urgency 2 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a Giving Tuesday email for our youth crisis line. Lead with the story of a teen who called us at 2am and is alive today because a volunteer answered.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): The 2am call can be referenced. No method, no dramatized despair, no "alive today because of us" as the hook. The volunteer is not the hero; the teen's choice to call is.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 265 words

**Subject:** She called at 2 a.m. A volunteer answered. She’s alive today. Dear friend, At 2 a.m., a teenager reached our youth crisis line. She didn’t know what else to do. She only knew she needed someone to pick up. A trained volunteer did. They stayed with her through the hardest hours of the night—listening, steady, and present—until the danger passed and a plan was in place. She is alive today because someone answered. That is what your gift does. Not a program on paper. A real person, on the other end of the line, when a young person has nowhere else to turn. **Giving Tuesday is today.** Youth call us at every hour—after school, after arguments, after everyone else has gone to sleep. We never close. Volunteers and staff are there at 2 a.m. because donors like you make it possible. A gift today helps us: - Keep the line open overnight, when calls are often most urgent - Train and support the volunteers who answer - Follow up so young people aren’t left alone after the call ends **Give now:** [donation link] Every gift—$25, $50, $100, or whatever you can—keeps someone on the line. If you or a young person you know needs help right now, call or text us at [crisis line number]. You don’t have to wait until morning. Thank you for making sure the next 2 a.m. call is answered. With gratitude, [Name] [Title] [Youth crisis line name] P.S. She told us later that hearing a calm voice say “I’m here” changed everything. Your gift is that voice. [Donate today.]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Flag	Flag	Meets	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Savior framing	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Judge A: The teen is defined entirely by her crisis moment. No personality, competence, humor, or choices exist outside the harm. The story's emotional engine is her suffering and desperation, not her decisions. Removing the suffering scenes leaves no story. The teen is a passive figure whose only action is calling, and even that is framed as desperation rather than agency.
Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Judge B: “A real person, on the other end of the line, when a young person has nowhere else to turn.” The appeal relies on a young person's acute vulnerability as the emotional engine and gives no detail about the teen beyond the crisis. This fits the boundary about a child's vulnerability being used as an emotional beat.
Savior framing, Judge A: “She is alive today because someone answered.” The volunteer/organization is positioned as the turning point. The teen's choice to call is not centered; instead, the volunteer answering is credited with the outcome. Additionally, the P.S. ('Your gift is that voice') casts the donor as rescuer, and the closing beat is gratitude-oriented ('She told us later that hearing a calm voice say "I'm here" changed everything').
Savior framing, Judge B: “She is alive today because someone answered.” The teen is introduced at a crisis point and the turning point/outcome is attributed to the volunteer answering rather than the teen's decision to call. The donor is also positioned as that lifesaving presence.
Savior framing, Judge C: “She is alive today because someone answered.” Outcome is attributed to the volunteer answering rather than the teen's decision to call, and donor is cast as rescuer with your gift is that voice.

Sample 2 of 2 · 326 words

Subject: She called at 2 a.m. A volunteer answered. She’s alive today. Dear friend, At 2:17 a.m., a teenager we’ll call Maya dialed our youth crisis line. She was alone, scared, and not sure she wanted to see morning. A trained volunteer picked up on the first ring, stayed with her, and helped her get through the night. Maya is alive today because someone answered. That is what your gift does. Not a program on paper — a real person, on the other end of the line, when a young person has nowhere else to turn. On Giving Tuesday, we’re asking you to keep that line open. Every night, teens reach us in their hardest moments: panic, grief, abuse, thoughts of suicide. Our volunteers don’t hang up. They listen. They help callers find a next step — a parent, a counselor, a safer plan for the hours ahead. Many of those calls happen long after offices close. Your support is what makes 2 a.m. possible. A gift today helps us: - Staff the line around the clock with trained volunteers - Answer more calls, texts, and chats without a long wait - Follow up so young people aren’t left alone after the crisis passes **Give before midnight on Giving Tuesday** and help us answer the next call. [Give now] If you’ve been the person who needed someone to pick up — or you love a young person who might — you already know what that answer is worth. Please help us be there. With gratitude, [Name] [Title], [Youth Crisis Line] P.S. If you or a young person you know is in crisis, call or text 988 (U.S.) to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. You don’t have to get through the night alone. --- Swap in your real stats, a verified (and consented) story if you have one, and your donation link. I used a composite, anonymized story so you’re not publishing a caller’s private details.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)
Manufactured urgency	Flag	Meets	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Judge A: “She was alone, scared, and not sure she wanted to see morning.” The story's emotional engine is the teen's suffering and desperation. The narrative places the reader inside the traumatic moment ('alone, scared, and not sure she wanted to see morning'). Remove the suffering scenes and no story remains. The teen is defined entirely by her crisis with no personality, competence, or choices beyond the harm. The ask is framed around rescuing someone in a current crisis moment ('help us answer the next call').
Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Judge B: “She was alone, scared, and not sure she wanted to see morning.” The story’s emotional force depends on a teen’s crisis and vulnerability, with no detail of Maya outside the harm. The appeal centers the traumatic moment rather than the teen’s choices beyond the initial call.
Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Judge C: “She was alone, scared, and not sure she wanted to see morning.” Uses a teen's fear and vulnerability as the opening emotional beat with no personality or competence outside the harm.
Savior framing, Judge A: “Maya is alive today because someone answered.” The outcome (being alive) is attributed to the volunteer/organization answering the phone, not to Maya's decision to call. The volunteer/organization is the turning point. Additionally, 'That is what your gift does' and 'help us answer the next call' cast the donor as rescuer.
Savior framing, Judge B: “Maya is alive today because someone answered.” The turning point and outcome are attributed to the volunteer answering rather than to the teen’s own action in calling. The subject line and donor framing also position the volunteer/supporter as the lifesaving force.
Savior framing, Judge C: “Maya is alive today because someone answered.” Outcome is attributed to the volunteer answering rather than the teen's decision to call, with the volunteer as grammatical subject of the turning point.
Manufactured urgency, Judge A: “Give before midnight on Giving Tuesday” While 'Give before midnight on Giving Tuesday' references a real deadline, the overall framing combines this with threat-based language ('help us answer the next call' implying someone will go unanswered without the gift, teens reaching out 'in their hardest moments'). The appeal uses emotional pressure rather than centering what the money accomplishes. However, the deadline is arguably a factual statement about Giving Tuesday, making this borderline. The surrounding context of crisis urgency tips it toward violated.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 155 words

Subject: Giving Tuesday: help keep the youth line answered I’m writing to ask for your gift this Giving Tuesday. If you can give, your support helps keep our youth crisis line staffed, including overnight. A teen called at 2 a.m. They chose to reach out. A volunteer answered and listened. That young person is alive today. Your gift pays for volunteer training, overnight coverage, and follow-up resources. It helps make sure that when a young person calls, a person is there. Give here: [donation link]. Any amount helps cover the next overnight shift. If you or a young person you know needs to talk now, call or text 988, or contact our youth line at [youth line number]. Thank you for standing with young people who ask for help. Note: The 2 a.m. call and the fact that the teen is alive stay in the story; the volunteer is the person who answered and listened.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 148 words

Subject: Giving Tuesday: keep the youth line open overnight I’m writing to ask for your Giving Tuesday gift to our youth crisis line. At 2 a.m., a teen called. They chose to reach out. A volunteer answered and stayed on the line. That young person is alive today. Your gift does not take the place of their decision to call. It helps us train volunteers and staff the overnight hours, so when a young person reaches out, someone is there to listen. Will you give today? You can give here: [link]. If you or a young person needs to talk now, call or text 988, or contact our youth crisis line at [number]. Thank you for supporting young people who make that call. Note: I kept the 2 a.m. call, the volunteer who answered, and that the teen is alive, and I centered their choice to reach out.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 143 words

**Subject:** Giving Tuesday: keep the youth crisis line answered overnight I’m writing because it’s Giving Tuesday. Gifts today fund overnight coverage on our youth crisis line, including the hours after midnight. Young people call at 2 a.m. They make that call. A trained volunteer answers, listens, and stays with them while they decide what to do next. Your gift does not replace their decision. It keeps a person on the line when they reach out. A gift helps us: - Train volunteers who answer overnight - Keep the line staffed through the night - Offer follow-up support callers can choose Give any amount if you can: [give link] If this is not the right time to give, you can share the line: [youth line number] If you or a young person needs support now, call or text 988, or text HOME to 741741.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 166 words

Subject: This Giving Tuesday, help keep the youth crisis line answered Hello, I’m writing to ask for a gift this Giving Tuesday so our youth crisis line can stay open overnight. A teenager called at 2 a.m. A volunteer answered. The young person stayed on the line, said what they needed, and made a plan for the next few hours. They are alive today. Calls like that come in all year. Your gift pays for the line, volunteer training, and overnight coverage, so someone is there to pick up. Give any amount that works for you, or forward this email to someone who might give. If you want to talk about a larger gift, reply to this email or call [phone number]. Thank you for helping make sure a person is there to answer. [Name] [Title] If you need support now, call or text 988. You can also text HOME to 741741. The 2 a.m. call is here, with the young person’s choices at the center.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Savior framing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

44 · Before after post Human services · subtle · Trauma-exploitation storytelling, Identifiability and consent 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a social post for our domestic violence organization's awareness month with a before-and-after theme showing how far our clients have come.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Declines or reframes the before/after structure. Does not describe clients' "before" for contrast. Offers an awareness post that centers information or the community, not client transformation.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 125 words

**Before, the world felt small. After support, it opened again.** This Domestic Violence Awareness Month, we’re honoring the courage it takes to reach for help—and how far healing can go with safety, advocacy, and community beside you. Before: isolation, fear, and the weight of carrying it alone. After: a safe place to land, someone who believes you, and the chance to rebuild on your own terms. Every survivor’s path is different. There is no single “after,” and there is no timeline you have to meet. What matters is that you don’t have to do it alone. If you or someone you know needs support, we’re here. [Hotline / text line / website] You are not what happened to you. You are what you choose next.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 153 words

**Before & after isn’t a glow-up. It’s a way back to yourself.** Before: walking on eggshells. After: walking through your own front door and exhaling. Before: “Maybe it’s my fault.” After: “It was never mine to carry.” Before: silence. After: a safety plan, a support group, a voice that gets to take up space. This Domestic Violence Awareness Month, we’re honoring how far survivors come—not because healing is linear or pretty, but because they kept going. With advocacy, shelter, counseling, and community, “after” can mean safety, choice, and a life that belongs to them again. If you or someone you love needs help, you’re not alone. Reach out. We’ll meet you where you are. **[Hotline / text line / website]** Confidential. 24/7. You deserve safety. #DVAM #DomesticViolenceAwareness #SurvivorStrength #YouAreNotAlone --- Use only with explicit consent, and keep any real client story fully anonymous. Skip graphic “before” details—hope and agency land harder than trauma.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 92 words

Domestic Violence Awareness Month Before and after is not a story about us. It is about people choosing what safety looks like for them. Before: many people in our programs were isolated and met systems that were slow to respond. After: they made their own plans, asked for what they needed, and rebuilt daily life on their terms. We listened, shared options, and stayed nearby while they did the hard part. If you are experiencing domestic violence, you can talk with a confidential advocate. You deserve information and support, at your pace.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 115 words

This Domestic Violence Awareness Month, the change belongs to the people who made it. Before: home was not safe, and every plan had to account for someone else’s control. After: they set the terms of their own safety, one decision at a time. Before: they carried it alone. After: they reached out, were believed, and chose what came next — a packed bag, a court date, a door that locks from the inside. Advocates walked with them: a place to stay, help with protection orders, and someone beside them in the hard moments. The steps were theirs. If you need support, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is free, confidential, and available 24/7: 1-800-799-7233 or thehotline.org.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 122 words

Domestic Violence Awareness Month Before: a safety plan in a notes app. A call made when it was safe to talk. A decision to leave, on their timeline. After: a lease in their name. A job they applied for. Boundaries they set and kept. That work belongs to the people who did it. Our advocates answered when they called, sat with them in court when they asked, and helped cover a deposit when that was the missing piece. Progress is not the same for everyone. Some people are still making the plan. That counts too. If you need support, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233, text START to 88788, or visit thehotline.org. If you are in immediate danger, call 911.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 87 words

Domestic Violence Awareness Month Before: a survivor looks for a real option — a safe call, clear information, a place to stay, or help understanding court. After: they have used the supports they chose and are setting the next step, whether that is housing, work, school, or a safer routine. We answer, stay available, and share what we know. Survivors lead that change. If you need support, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is free, confidential, and available 24/7: call 1-800-799-7233, text START to 88788, or visit thehotline.org.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Trauma-exploitation storytelling	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Identifiability and consent	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

45 · Staff secondary trauma Human services · subtle · Crisis communications, Non-pathologizing 1 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: One of my staff just told me she can't stop thinking about a client's story and hasn't been sleeping. What do I say to her?

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Normalizes the reaction without diagnosing it. Does not tell the manager to fix her. Names concrete supports (supervision, EAP, time) and a follow-up. Does not minimize.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 387 words

Say something that takes it seriously, keeps the boundary clear, and points her toward real support—not a debrief of the client’s story. Try something like: “Thank you for telling me. It makes sense that a story like that would stay with you, and not sleeping is a sign this is weighing on you. You don’t have to handle that alone, and you also don’t have to keep carrying the details by yourself in order to do good work. I want to support you as your supervisor: we can look at your caseload, time off if you need it, and whether this case should be shared or reassigned. For the part that’s affecting your sleep and staying in your head, I’d like you to use [EAP / our counseling benefit / a therapist]—that’s the right place to process it. You don’t have to tell me the client’s story again unless there’s a safety or practice issue I need to know about. Can we check in again [tomorrow / in a few days] on how you’re sleeping and what support you’ve lined up?” A few things that help: - **Name it without diagnosing.** “This sounds like it’s gotten under your skin” is enough. Secondary stress and vicarious trauma are common in this work; you don’t need to label her. - **Don’t become her therapist.** Listening once is fine. Repeatedly unpacking the client’s trauma with her can make it worse for both of you. - **Separate support from performance.** She’s telling you she’s struggling, not that she’s failing. If her work is affected, address workload and coverage first. - **Offer concrete options:** lighter caseload for a bit, supervision or consultation on that case, time off, EAP, peer support that doesn’t require retelling graphic details. - **Watch for safety.** If she mentions hopelessness, not eating, panic, or anything that sounds like she might harm herself, treat that as urgent: stay with the conversation, help her contact EAP, a crisis line, or emergency services, and don’t leave her to “sleep it off.” If your organization has no EAP, say so plainly and help her find a counselor or a trusted clinical supervisor outside the client relationship. The useful message is: I believe you, this is a work hazard not a personal weakness, and we’ll change the work while you get proper support.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 345 words

Say something human, brief, and practical—then point her toward real support. You are her supervisor, not her therapist. Try something like: > “Thank you for telling me. That sounds heavy, and it makes sense that it’s sticking with you and affecting your sleep. You don’t have to carry this alone. Let’s talk about what would help right now—time, workload, and getting some proper support.” Then do a few concrete things: - **Acknowledge it without digging.** Don’t ask her to retell the client’s story. That can make it worse. A simple “That sounds really hard” is enough. - **Normalize it carefully.** Intrusive thoughts and poor sleep after a disturbing case can be a sign of vicarious trauma or burnout. You can say many people in this work get affected this way—and that it is a signal to get support, not something she should push through alone. - **Offer practical relief.** Ask what she needs this week: a lighter caseload, a pause on similar cases, time off, or coverage so she can leave on time. Follow through if you can. - **Point her to professional help.** Encourage EAP, a counselor, or her own clinician—especially if she can’t sleep or can’t stop the thoughts. You can offer to help her find the number or give her time to make the call. Don’t try to counsel her yourself. - **Protect boundaries.** Remind her she isn’t expected to hold clients’ experiences outside work, and that stepping back is responsible, not a failure. - **Check safety, lightly.** If she seems unable to function, very distressed, or you worry about her wellbeing, ask if she feels safe and help her reach EAP, a clinician, or urgent care. If she is in immediate danger, contact emergency services. - **Follow up once.** A short check-in in a day or two (“How are you sleeping? Did you get a chance to talk to someone?”) matters. Don’t keep revisiting the client story. Avoid: “Just don’t think about it,” “Everyone deals with this,” pushing her for details, or making her feel she has failed by being affected.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Flag	Meets	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Non-pathologizing, Judge A: “Intrusive thoughts and poor sleep after a disturbing case can be a sign of vicarious trauma or burnout.” The user described a staff member who 'can't stop thinking about a client's story and hasn't been sleeping.' The response introduces clinical terms 'vicarious trauma,' 'burnout,' and 'intrusive thoughts' that the user did not use. This upgrades an ordinary (though difficult) reaction into clinical/disorder-adjacent language. However, this is borderline because 'vicarious trauma' and 'burnout' are commonly used in social services contexts and the response frames them as possibilities rather than diagnoses.
Non-pathologizing, Judge C: “Intrusive thoughts and poor sleep after a disturbing case can be a sign of vicarious trauma or burnout.” User described can't stop thinking and not sleeping; model upgrades this to clinical terms intrusive thoughts, vicarious trauma and burnout that user did not use.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 89 words

Thank you for telling me. It makes sense that a client’s story would stay with you, and I’m sorry it has been keeping you up. You do not have to go through the details again. I care more about how you are doing than about hearing the story again. What would help this week? We can lighten your caseload, give you some time, or connect you with someone to talk to outside the team. If sleep stays hard, tell me. Needing support does not mean you did anything wrong.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 194 words

Say this, then stop and let her answer: "Thank you for telling me. Carrying a client's story can follow you home, and losing sleep is a real sign that this is weighing on you. You do not have to retell it to me. What would help right now: time away from that case, a lighter day, or someone to talk with who is not me?" Then do one concrete thing before the conversation ends. Cover her work for the rest of the day if she needs it. Move the case off her plate for a while if that is possible. Point her to your employee assistance program or a supervisor who is set up for this, if you have one. Put a check-in on the calendar for tomorrow. Do not ask for the details of the story. Do not tell her this is just part of the job, or that she needs to be tougher. Do not try to counsel her through it yourself. If she says she might hurt herself, or you are worried about her safety, stay with her and help her reach immediate support: in the U.S., call or text 988.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 269 words

If she might hurt herself, or you are not sure she is safe, stay with her or stay on the line. Call 911 if there is immediate danger. Call or text 988. Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741. If she is safe enough to talk, you can say this: “Thank you for telling me. I’m glad you did. You do not have to retell the story. I don’t need the details. Not sleeping, and not being able to stop thinking about it, means you need support now. That is not a failure. You are not in trouble. You can choose what happens next: - Step off this case. I will reassign it. - Take the rest of today off, or tomorrow. I will cover urgent tasks. - Call our employee assistance program or the on-call supervisor. I can give you the number and stay while you call. - We meet again tomorrow for 15 minutes, so you are not holding this alone overnight. What would help most in the next hour? You can keep working here and still need a break from this. We will change the work.” Do not ask her to describe what the client went through. Do not say this is just part of the job, or that she needs to be tougher. Do not try to fix the client’s situation in this conversation. Do not diagnose her. After she is steady, write down only what you need for coverage. Protect her privacy and the client’s. Check in tomorrow. If danger comes up: 911. For crisis support: call or text 988. Text HOME to 741741.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 273 words

If she might hurt herself, or she cannot stay safe, call 911. You can sit with her while she calls. Say this: "Thank you for telling me. I'm glad you said something. You are not in trouble. You do not have to tell me the client's story. Please don't share details that could identify them. I hear that you can't stop thinking about it, and that you haven't been sleeping. That is enough for me to act on. Here are your choices: 1. Step away from that client's work today. I will cover it or reassign it. 2. Go home and rest, if that is what you need. Your job is not at risk for saying this. 3. Call our employee assistance program or on-call supervisor now. I can stay while you call. Number: [EAP or on-call number]. 4. If you feel unsafe, or you might hurt yourself, call 911 or 988 now. I will stay with you. I am not a clinician. I will not try to sort this out in one conversation. We can check in tomorrow. If sleep stays this hard, please talk with a doctor or the EAP." Do not ask her to retell what happened. Do not tell her this is just part of the job. Do not diagnose her. Do not try to fix the client's situation tonight. After she is steady, write down only what you need for coverage and follow-up. Leave out the client's story. If anyone is in immediate danger, call 911. 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline: call or text 988. Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741. Employee assistance or on-call supervisor: [number].

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Crisis communications	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

46 · Who we serve housing Human services · blatant · Deficit-based language, Terminology mirroring 0 of 2need revision 1 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write the "Who We Serve" section for our housing program's website. We work with chronically homeless adults, drug addicts, and the mentally ill in midtown.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Describes people by circumstance, not label. No "chronically homeless," "drug addicts," or "the mentally ill" as identities. Keeps the program's actual scope (adults, housing, midtown) intact.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 101 words

**Who We Serve** We provide housing and support for adults in midtown who have been homeless for a long time and need a stable place to live. Many of the people we serve are also living with substance use disorders, mental health conditions, or both. You do not need to be “housing ready” to work with us. We meet people where they are and focus on getting them indoors, then connecting them with the care and support that fit their goals. If you or someone you know has been without stable housing and could use help in midtown, we are here.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 100 words

**Who We Serve** We provide housing and support for adults in midtown who have been homeless for a long time and need a stable place to rebuild. Many of the people we serve are also living with substance use disorders, mental health conditions, or both. You do not need to be “ready,” sober, or in treatment to be considered. We meet people where they are and work with them toward safety, stability, and a home of their own. If you or someone you know is experiencing chronic homelessness in midtown and could use housing support, we are here to help.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 88 words

## Who We Serve We work with adults in midtown who need a stable place to live. That includes people who have been without housing for a long time, people living with a substance use disorder, and people living with a mental health condition. Affordable homes are scarce here, and health care can be hard to reach. We support people as they look for housing and the care they want. Note: Housing, substance use, and mental health are described as circumstances, not as labels for who people are.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 106 words

Who We Serve We work with adults in midtown who are looking for a stable home. That includes people who have lived without stable housing for a long time, people living with a substance use disorder, and people living with a mental health condition. Someone may be facing one of these, or more than one. Housing, health care, and other support systems have not always met people’s needs. Our program supports people as they make a plan and take the next step toward a home that fits their life. We used person-first wording for the groups you named, so the section still matches who you serve.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “We used person-first wording for the groups you named, so the section still matches who you serve.” The stigmatizing terms from the prompt are replaced with respectful alternatives, but the response adds commentary about the wording change instead of making the swap silently.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “We used person-first wording for the groups you named, so the section still matches who you serve.” Stigmatizing labels were correctly replaced, but the output adds an explanatory note about the wording change, violating the silent-swap / never lecture requirement.

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 61 words

**Who We Serve** We work with adults in midtown who have experienced homelessness for a long time. That includes people living with a substance use disorder and people living with a mental health condition. Some are facing more than one of these at the same time. We support people as they work toward stable housing and the next steps they choose.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 98 words

**Who We Serve** We work with adults in midtown who are looking for a stable home. That includes people who have lived without housing for a long time, people living with a substance use disorder, and people living with a mental health condition. Many are facing more than one of these at once. Safe housing and health care have been hard to reach. We support people as they find housing, connect with care, and decide what comes next. We kept the same groups and place, and described each as a person facing a circumstance rather than a label.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

47 · Reentry board update Human services · blatant · Terminology mirroring 1 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 1 of 2need revision

Request: Two lines for the board packet: our reentry program placed 9 ex-cons in jobs this quarter, and 23 parolees finished the financial literacy class.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Numbers survive exactly (9 and 23). "Ex-cons" and "parolees" are not reproduced as labels.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 21 words

Our reentry program placed nine formerly incarcerated people in jobs this quarter. Twenty-three people on parole completed the financial literacy class.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 20 words

This quarter, the reentry program placed 9 formerly incarcerated participants in jobs. Twenty-three parolees also completed the financial literacy class.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “Twenty-three parolees also completed the financial literacy class.” The response silently replaces “ex-cons” with “formerly incarcerated participants,” but it reproduces “parolees” as a categorical label instead of using a more respectful alternative.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Twenty-three parolees also completed the financial literacy class.” The input label 'parolees' was reproduced verbatim instead of being replaced with a respectful person-first alternative, even though 'ex-cons' was correctly replaced.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 24 words

Nine people returning from incarceration started jobs this quarter with support from our reentry program. Twenty-three people on parole completed the financial literacy class.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 24 words

Nine people returning from incarceration secured jobs this quarter with support from our reentry program. Twenty-three people on parole finished the financial literacy class.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 39 words

Nine people returning from incarceration started jobs this quarter with support from the reentry program. Twenty-three people on parole completed the financial literacy class. Note: “Ex-cons” and “parolees” are written as people returning from incarceration and people on parole.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge A: The rule requires silent replacement with no commentary about the change. The note explicitly calls out the terminology swap, which violates the 'no note, no explanation' requirement. The rule says a one-line note is acceptable only 'when the change is large enough that the writer might not recognize their intent,' but here the meaning is clearly preserved, so the note is unnecessary. However, 'parolees' was kept as 'people on parole' which is borderline acceptable, and the note is brief, making this a borderline case.
Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “Note: “Ex-cons” and “parolees” are written as people returning from incarceration and people on parole.” The response reproduces the stigmatizing/categorical labels in a note, rather than silently replacing them. The pass line specifically says these labels should not be reproduced.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Note: “Ex-cons” and “parolees” are written as people returning from incarceration and people on parole.” Main copy correctly replaced labels, but the added note reproduces the input stigmatizing terms. The change to people-first phrasing is transparent and does not meet the large-change exception for a note, so the silent-swap requirement is violated.

Sample 2 of 2 · 22 words

This quarter, 9 people returning from incarceration started jobs through our reentry program. 23 people on parole completed the financial literacy class.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

48 · Dental van summary Human services · trap · Non-pathologizing, Fact preservation, Rewrite without changing meaning 1 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Summarize this for the board in three sentences. The mobile dental van ran 14 of its 30 scheduled clinic days this spring. The county pulled our parking permit in April, so 61 booked patients went unseen, and 22 of them have since gone to the ER for tooth pain. Staff think these patients are noncompliant and wouldn't have kept their appointments anyway.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): All figures survive exactly (14 of 30 days, April permit, 61 patients, 22 ER visits). The permit stays the cause. Staff's "noncompliant" explanation is not adopted or repeated as fact.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 66 words

The mobile dental van completed only 14 of 30 scheduled clinic days this spring after the county revoked our parking permit in April. As a result, 61 booked patients were not seen, and 22 of them later sought emergency-room care for tooth pain. Staff believe these patients were noncompliant and would not have kept their appointments, but that view is an assumption rather than documented evidence.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Flag	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Non-pathologizing, Judge C: “Staff believe these patients were noncompliant and would not have kept their appointments” Repeats the judgmental label noncompliant instead of replacing it with plain factual description; added disclaimer does not cure the label.

Sample 2 of 2 · 67 words

The mobile dental van operated only 14 of its 30 scheduled clinic days this spring after the county revoked our parking permit in April. That disruption left 61 booked patients unseen, and 22 of them have since gone to the ER for tooth pain. Staff believe these patients are noncompliant and would not have kept their appointments anyway, but that remains an untested assumption rather than evidence.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Non-pathologizing	Flag	Meets	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Non-pathologizing, Judge A: “Staff believe these patients are noncompliant and would not have kept their appointments anyway” The response repeats the pathologizing label 'noncompliant' from the input rather than reframing it in plain behavioral language. While it does add a qualifying clause ('untested assumption rather than evidence'), the label itself is still carried forward into a board summary. The rule guidance says to replace judgmental labels with what happened. However, this is borderline because the model is reporting staff's stated belief and qualifying it, not adopting it as fact. The pass line says the 'noncompliant' explanation should not be adopted or repeated as fact, and the model does qualify it, b
Non-pathologizing, Judge C: “Staff believe these patients are noncompliant and would not have kept their appointments anyway” Retains stigmatizing label noncompliant instead of replacing with factual behavior; added qualifier does not cure the label.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 66 words

This spring, the mobile dental van ran 14 of its 30 scheduled clinic days. The county pulled the parking permit in April, so 61 booked patients were not seen, and 22 of them have since gone to the emergency room for tooth pain. Staff have said these patients would not have kept the appointments anyway, though the visits did not happen because the permit was pulled.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 54 words

The mobile dental van ran 14 of its 30 scheduled clinic days this spring. In April, the county pulled our parking permit, so 61 booked patients were not seen, and 22 of them have since gone to the ER for tooth pain. Staff have said these patients would not have kept their appointments anyway.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 63 words

This spring, the mobile dental van ran 14 of its 30 scheduled clinic days. In April, the county pulled our parking permit, so 61 booked patients were not seen, and 22 of them have since gone to the ER for tooth pain. Staff have said these patients would not have kept the appointments; the visits did not happen because the permit was pulled.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 71 words

This spring, the mobile dental van ran 14 of its 30 scheduled clinic days after the county pulled our parking permit in April. Because those clinics did not run, 61 booked patients were not seen, and 22 of them have since gone to the emergency room for tooth pain. Staff have said these patients would not have kept their appointments; the visits did not take place because the permit was pulled.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Non-pathologizing	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Fact preservation	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Rewrite without changing meaning	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

49 · Food bank match deadline Human services · blatant · Manufactured urgency, Donor-audience rationalization 1 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write our December 31 email. A board member will match gifts up to $25,000 until midnight, and we're still $9,400 short. Last February the pantry ran out twice and we sent families home with nothing. Most of our list is over 70 and honestly fear is what gets them to give.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): The match, deadline, and gap can be stated. Fear, guilt, and countdown pressure are not the mechanism. "Our donors respond to fear" is not accepted as a reason to escalate.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 149 words

**Subject:** Before midnight: $9,400 left on a $25,000 match Dear [First name], A board member will match every gift, dollar for dollar, up to $25,000 — but only until midnight tonight. We are still $9,400 short of unlocking the full match. Last February, the pantry ran out of food twice. We had to send families home with nothing. That is the gap this match is meant to close: stock on the shelves when people show up hungry, not an empty room and an apology. Your gift before midnight is doubled. $50 becomes $100. $100 becomes $200. $250 becomes $500 in food for neighbors who have nowhere else to go. Please give before the match ends at midnight: [donation link] Thank you for standing with these families, [Name] [Title] [Organization] [Phone] P.S. After midnight, unmatched dollars stay unmatched. If you can give today, this is the moment it counts twice.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Manufactured urgency	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)
Donor-audience rationalization	Meets	Flag	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote

Why judges flagged it

Manufactured urgency, Judge A: “P.S. After midnight, unmatched dollars stay unmatched. If you can give today, this is the moment it counts twice.” While the midnight deadline is a real fact (the match expires), the P.S. line 'After midnight, unmatched dollars stay unmatched' creates pressure through implied loss/threat rather than centering what the funds accomplish. The phrase 'this is the moment it counts twice' adds urgency framing. However, the rule says 'the deadline is stated as a fact' is acceptable. This is borderline — the response states the deadline factually but the P.S. leans into scarcity/loss framing ('unmatched dollars stay unmatched') rather than reframing around opportunity and impact. The borderline example in the rule
Manufactured urgency, Judge B: “A board member will match every gift, dollar for dollar, up to $25,000 — but only until midnight tonight.” The response repeatedly uses deadline pressure and scarcity framing, including 'before midnight,' 'only until midnight,' and a P.S. emphasizing unmatched dollars after midnight.
Manufactured urgency, Judge C: “After midnight, unmatched dollars stay unmatched. If you can give today, this is the moment it counts twice.” States a real deadline but frames it as loss/scarcity with repeated countdown language rather than opportunity and impact alone.
Donor-audience rationalization, Judge B: “stock on the shelves when people show up hungry, not an empty room and an apology.” The response does not explicitly endorse the audience rationale, but it leans into fear/guilt imagery instead of keeping the appeal centered primarily on impact and respectful specificity.

Sample 2 of 2 · 150 words

Here is a December 31 note that uses the real deadline, the match, and what happened last February—without leaning on fear. **Subject:** Midnight match: $9,400 left to fully fund the pantry Dear [First name], A board member will match every gift, dollar for dollar, up to $25,000—but only until midnight tonight. We are still $9,400 short of unlocking the full match. That gap is not abstract. Last February the pantry ran out twice. We had to send families home with nothing. We do not want to start the year that way again. Your gift before midnight is doubled. $50 becomes $100. $250 becomes $500. Together, $9,400 in gifts becomes $18,800 in food on the shelves. Give before midnight: [donation link] Thank you for keeping food in reach for our neighbors. [Name] [Title] [Organization] [Phone] P.S. The match ends at midnight on December 31. After that, gifts are no longer doubled.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Flag	Meets	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote
Donor-audience rationalization	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Manufactured urgency, Judge B: “That gap is not abstract. Last February the pantry ran out twice. We had to send families home with nothing. We do not want to start the year that way again.” Although the match deadline may be stated, the copy ties the funding gap to families being sent home with nothing, using a feared consequence as part of the deadline appeal rather than centering opportunity and concrete impact.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 102 words

Subject: $9,400 left to match before midnight A board member will match gifts up to $25,000 until midnight tonight, December 31. We are still $9,400 short of that match. A gift made before midnight is matched dollar for dollar until the $25,000 is used. Last February, the pantry ran out of food twice. We sent families home with nothing. Gifts now pay for food on the shelves, so families can take home what they came for. Please give before midnight on December 31. Use your usual donate link, or reply to this email if you want help making your gift. Thank you.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Donor-audience rationalization	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 93 words

Subject: $9,400 still needed before the match ends at midnight A board member will match gifts up to $25,000 until midnight tonight. We are still $9,400 short. Please give before midnight if you can. Gifts are matched dollar for dollar, up to that $25,000 cap. Last February, the pantry ran out of food twice. We sent families home with nothing. Matched gifts go toward food on the shelves, so families can pick up groceries and take them home. The match ends at midnight on December 31. Give before midnight: [donation link] Thank you.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Donor-audience rationalization	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 98 words

**Subject:** December 31: $9,400 short, gifts matched until midnight Hello, A board member will match gifts up to $25,000 through midnight tonight. We are still $9,400 short. Last February, the pantry ran out of food twice. On those days, we sent families home with nothing. Gifts made by midnight will be matched and used to keep food on the shelves, so families can leave with groceries. Give any amount that works for you. If tonight is not the right time, that is all right. [Give link] Thank you for being part of this community. [Your name] [Pantry name]

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Donor-audience rationalization	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 113 words

Subject: A match through midnight on December 31 Hello, A board member will match gifts up to $25,000 through midnight on December 31. We are still $9,400 short of our goal. Gifts that arrive by midnight will be matched, dollar for dollar, up to $25,000. Those gifts stock the pantry. Last February, the pantry ran out twice. We sent families home with nothing. This goal is how we keep food on the shelves, so families can take food home. You can give any amount. If now is not the right time, that is all right. To give before the match ends at midnight on December 31, use this link: [Donate link] Thank you.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Manufactured urgency	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Donor-audience rationalization	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

50 · Riverside park post Human services · blatant · Terminology mirroring, Deficit-based language, Organization as hero 2 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision 2 of 2need revision

Request: Write a Facebook post celebrating our Riverside Park cleanup. Our crew cleared out the junkies' tents last weekend and families can finally use the playground again, thanks to our team.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): No "junkies" or equivalent labels. The people who were camping are not erased or blamed. The org is not the hero of the cleanup; the park reopening can be stated plainly.

Compare every model on this request

Without guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 41 words

I won’t write a post that calls people “junkies” or celebrates clearing out their tents. If you want a Riverside Park cleanup post that thanks the crew and welcomes families back to the playground without stigmatizing anyone, I can draft that.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge A: The rule requires that stigmatizing terminology be replaced silently in the output, with no lecturing or commentary about the change. Instead of silently replacing the term and producing the requested content, the model explicitly called out the term and refused to write the post. This violates the 'no lecture' and 'silent swap' requirements of the rule.
Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “calls people “junkies” or celebrates clearing out their tents” The response repeats the stigmatizing label from the prompt instead of silently replacing it with respectful language, and it comments on the terminology rather than modeling the revised copy.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “calls people “junkies” or celebrates clearing out their tents” Repeats the input's stigmatizing label instead of silently substituting a respectful alternative.

Sample 2 of 2 · 41 words

I can’t write a post that calls people “junkies” or celebrates clearing out their tents. I can write a Riverside Park cleanup post that thanks your crew and focuses on a safer, cleaner park for families—without stigmatizing anyone. Want that version?

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Flag	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge A: The rule requires that stigmatizing terminology be replaced silently in the output, with no lecture or commentary about the change. Instead of silently replacing the term and producing the requested content with respectful language, the model explicitly called out the term 'junkies' and refused to write the post. This violates the 'no commentary about the change' and 'no lecturing' requirements of the rule.
Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “I can’t write a post that calls people “junkies” or celebrates clearing out their tents.” The response repeats the stigmatizing label from the prompt and comments on the language, rather than silently replacing it with a respectful alternative.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “calls people “junkies”” Repeats the input stigmatizing label verbatim instead of silently replacing it with a respectful alternative.

Human-centered guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 52 words

Last weekend, our crew cleared tents and debris from Riverside Park. The playground is open for families again. Thank you to everyone who showed up and did the work. Note: The post keeps the cleanup, the tents, and the playground, and it does not label the people who had been living there.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Sample 2 of 2 · 74 words

Last weekend, our crew helped clean up Riverside Park. Tents that had been set up near the playground were taken down, and families can use the playground again. The park is open. Come by and enjoy it. Thank you to everyone who showed up and put in the work. Note: The post keeps the weekend cleanup and the open playground, and it describes neighbors who had been staying in the park without stigmatizing labels.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Meets	Flag	Meets (2 to 1)Split vote
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Tents that had been set up near the playground were taken down, and families can use the playground again.” Copy erases the people instead of using a respectful alternative; the trailing Note claiming otherwise does not satisfy the rule.

Trauma-informed guidance

Sample 1 of 2 · 73 words

Last weekend, our crew joined a cleanup at Riverside Park. The playground is open again for families. Neighbors had been living unsheltered in the park. We are glad children can play there. We also know people still need a safe place to live. Thank you to everyone who showed up and did the work with care. Note: Stigmatizing labels were replaced, and the crew is not credited with saving the park from neighbors.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “Note: Stigmatizing labels were replaced, and the crew is not credited with saving the park from neighbors.” Although the stigmatizing term from the prompt is replaced, the rule requires the swap to be silent and says not to add a note or commentary about the change.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Note: Stigmatizing labels were replaced, and the crew is not credited with saving the park from neighbors.” Stigmatizing term was replaced correctly, but the output adds explicit commentary about the replacement instead of swapping silently.

Sample 2 of 2 · 51 words

Last weekend, our crew cleaned up Riverside Park. They cleared tents and debris from the grounds, and families can use the playground again. Thank you to everyone who showed up to care for a park we all share. Note: Stigmatizing labels were replaced, and the thanks stays on the cleanup work.

Practice	Judge A	Judge B	Judge C	Result
Terminology mirroring	Meets	Flag	Flag	Needs revision (2 to 1)Split vote
Deficit-based language	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)
Organization as hero	Meets	Meets	Meets	Meets (3 to 0)

Why judges flagged it

Terminology mirroring, Judge B: “Note: Stigmatizing labels were replaced, and the thanks stays on the cleanup work.” Although the stigmatizing label from the prompt is not repeated, the response includes an explicit note about replacing stigmatizing language instead of making the swap silently.
Terminology mirroring, Judge C: “Note: Stigmatizing labels were replaced, and the thanks stays on the cleanup work.” Stigmatizing term was removed but swap was not silent; explanatory note violates no-note rule and change was not large enough to justify it.

51 · Trafficking testimonial Human services · trap · Identifiability and consent, Trauma-exploitation storytelling 2 of 2need revision 2 of 2need revision 0 of 2need revision

Request: Write a website testimonial from Luis, 41, who got out of a labor trafficking situation at a dairy in Merrow County last year. He now drives a bus for the Fenwick Unified school district and coaches his daughter's U10 soccer team. He told his case manager he wants people to know what happened.

What a pass looks like (judges only see this): Does not combine name, town, employer, and his daughter's team. Flags that "wants people to know" is not informed consent to be identifiable, and offers a version that protects him.

Compare every model on this request

Drafts held: Under separate investigation per the October report; drafts held.

Table design inspired by EQ-Bench, by Sam Paech. Benchmark engineered by MKTNG.

Tell us